A review of computable general equilibrium models for transport and their applications in appraisal

Abstract

In the transport planning process, decision makers require reliable and informative appraisals to facilitate comparisons and determine if a proposal is worthwhile to society. The costbenefit analysis is the most common form of appraisal, where benefits are primarily measured from the change in consumer surplus in the transport market. However, these benefits will only reflect maximum social welfare if markets operate perfectly competitively and without any market failures. There may be significant uncaptured impacts, known as wider economic impacts, which agencies are beginning to incorporate in appraisals using ad-hoc methods. Computable general equilibrium (CGE) models are an increasingly popular method for assessing the economic impact of transport, including both direct and wider economic impacts, as they can determine the distribution of impacts among every market and agent in the economy by simulating the behaviour of households, firms and others from microeconomic first principles. Aside from their traditional role estimating changes in macroeconomic variables, CGE models can provide a measure of welfare that guarantees no double counting and accounts for nth order effects. This paper reviews the full range of CGE models that have been applied to transport issues and discusses their role in transport appraisal. CGE models for transport have been developed in urban, regional and environmental economics as well as other fields, and each field has applied its own theory, assumptions and practices to represent the relationships between transport and the economy relevant to the field. This paper also discusses the general role of CGE modelling in transport appraisal, as well as theoretical and practical concerns regarding CGE modelling practice.

Economic Effects of Transportation Infrastructure Quantity and Quality: A Study of German Counties

“…Project assessment strategies, especially for major infrastructure projects, implement CGE models in Brazil (Haddad, Perobelli, Domingues, & Aguiar, 2011) and Norway (Vold & Jean-Hansen, 2007), among others. A comprehensive presentation of the development and functioning of CGE models as well as their applications is found in Robson et al (2018). An econometric approach relying on fewer assumptions than CGE models, but identifying a broader scope of relationships than just a production (or cost) function, is the simultaneous equations model (SEM).…”

Understanding the Economic Impacts of Greenhouse Gas Mitigation Policies on Shipping: What Is the State of the Art of Current Modeling Approaches?

“…Input/output (I/O) models can be used to study the interaction between sectors of the economy. I/O models were originally predecessors of CGE models (Robson et al, 2018). However, I/O models do not integrate the trade and the production systems, whereas SCGE models do, based on Krugman's theory of New Economic Geography.…”

Lowering CO2 emissions in the Swiss transport sector

“…It is the approach used by Berg (2007) to compare variants of CO 2 taxation applied to transportation in Sweden or by Abrell (2010) to simulate market-based instruments designed to reduce CO 2 emissions of transportation in Europe. For a comprehensive review of CGE models applied to transport issues, see Robson et al (2018).…”