Cardiac troponin I (cTnI) contains a N-terminal extension harboring protein kinase A targets (Ser23/24), which are phosphorylated during β-adrenergic stimulation to increase cardiomyocyte relaxation rate. Here, we show that exon 3 of TNNI3, encoding most of the cTnI N-terminal extension including Ser23/24, was pseudoexonized multiple times in shrews and moles to mimic Ser23/24 phosphorylation without adrenergic stimulation, thus facilitating the evolution of exceptionally high resting heart rates (>1100 beats/minute). Cardiac transcriptomes further reveal alternative splicing of TNNI3 exon 3 in two distantly related bat families, thereby representing an intermediate state preceding the genomic assimilation of exon 3 skipping. As human TNNI3 may similarly be amenable to exon 3 alternative splicing, our results offer a new approach to restore diastolic function in chronic heart failure patients.