A Role for the X Chromosome in Sex Differences in Variability in General Intelligence?

Abstract

There is substantial evidence that males are more variable than females in general intelligence. In recent years, researchers have presented this as a reason that, although there is little, if any, mean sex difference in general intelligence, males tend to be overrepresented at both ends of its overall distribution. Part of the explanation could be the presence of genes on the X chromosome related both to syndromal disorders involving mental retardation and to population variation in general intelligence occurring normally. Genes on the X chromosome appear overrepresented among genes with known involvement in mental retardation, which is consistent with a model we developed of the population distribution of general intelligence as a mixture of two normal distributions. Using this model, we explored the expected ratios of males to females at various points in the distribution and estimated the proportion of variance in general intelligence potentially due to genes on the X chromosome. These estimates provide clues to the extent to which biologically based sex differences could be manifested in the environment as sex differences in displayed intellectual abilities. We discuss these observations in the context of sex differences in specific cognitive abilities and evolutionary theories of sexual selection.

Individual Differences in the Discrimination of Novel Speech Sounds: Effects of Sex, Temporal Processing, Musical and Cognitive Abilities

“…One question that arises is why are there no sex differences in general intelligence given a sex difference in temporal processing and a link between temporal processing and intelligence? Indeed, mean sex differences in general intelligence have generally proven to be elusive [49] despite sex differences in reaction times [50] and temporal processing [16]. However, a review of research on sex differences in various timed tests reveals that men are faster in reaction time and finger tapping tests while women are faster in naming and symbol copying, with neither sex outperforming the other in general intelligence [51].…”

Genetic foundations of human intelligence

“…The existence of genes, on any chromosome, with differential effects on specific kinds of abilities would be consistent with the idea of g as an emergent trait influenced by different genes to different degrees in different individuals. Johnson et al (2009) provide a more complete review of the reasons for thinking genes on the X chromosome may be involved in intelligence.…”

On the Importance of Tail Ratios for Psychological Science

“…Whereas tail ratios have only quite recently been discussed in the literature (see below), the calculation and interpretation of variance ratios has a long and checkered history throughout the 20th century (for historical overviews, see Feingold, 1992b;Hedges & Nowell, 1995b;Johnson, Carothers, & Deary, 2009). Interest in variance ratios apparently emerged before 1900 in the context of evolutionary theorizing, specifi cally regarding the so-called greater male variability hypothesis, i.e., the notion that variance across many psychological (including intellectual) traits is larger in the male than in the female sex.…”