A scoping review of literature assessing the impact of the learning assistant model

Abstract

Much of modern education reform is focused on implementation of evidenced-based teaching, but these techniques are sometimes met with trepidation from faculty, due to inexperience or lack of necessary resources. One near-peer teaching model designed to facilitate evidenced-based teaching in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics classrooms is the Learning Assistant (LA) model. Here, we describe the details of the LA model, present a scoping review of literature using the four original goals of the LA model as a framework, and suggest future areas of research that would deepen our understanding of the impact that the LA model may have on education. We summarize how the LA model improves student outcomes and teacher preparation and identify a relative deficiency of literature that addresses how the LA model impacts faculty and departmental/institutional change. Additionally, of the 39 papers reviewed, 11 are strictly pre-experimental study designs, 28 use quasi-experimental designs or a combination of quasi and pre-experimental, and none of them included a true experimental design. Thus, we conclude that current studies suggest that LA model positively impacts education, but more refined assessment would improve our understanding of the model. Furthermore, despite the encouraging research on the impact of the LA model and the proliferation of LA programs at institutions across the world, the study of the LA model has been, for the most part, limited to a small group of education researchers. Therefore, a major objective of this review is to introduce the LA model to a new group of instructors and researchers who can further our understanding of this promising model.

A QuantCrit Investigation of Society’s Educational Debts Due to Racism and Sexism in Chemistry Student Learning

“…The analyzed data came from 4,612 students in 39 first semester introductory college chemistry courses.The courses were taught at 12 institutions, including one two-year college, two private universities, and three minority-serving institutions. Thirty-two of the courses used the Learning Assistant Model57,58 to implement collaborative instruction. All 39 courses reported using collaborative learning.Sixteen of the courses completed a survey on their teaching practices implemented in the Spring of 2019.…”

The role of epistemological beliefs in STEM faculty’s decisions to use culturally relevant pedagogy at Hispanic-Serving Institutions

“…I am currently an assistant professor at a research-intensive institution, but I worked for 5 years at a regional HSI and 5 years as a high school science teacher. My experiences at the HSI teaching physics courses to future elementary teachers and supporting my colleagues in transforming their STEM courses using Learning Assistants (Barrasso & Spilios, 2021 ) informed my perspective on this project. They provided me insight into the deep care that many HSI instructors have for their students and the structural barriers that often prevent them from supporting their diverse students in the holistic ways that they want.…”

Societal Educational Debts Due to Racism and Sexism in Calculus-based Electricity and Magnetism Courses

“…The data came from 3,686 students in 83 courses from 14 institutions. Of the 83 courses, 66 used the learning assistant model [58,59] to implement collaborative instruc-FIG. 1: Society's educational debts before and after instruction with three potential outcomes: mitigate, perpetuate, or exacerbate.…”