A self‐determination theory analysis of reflective debrief themes about dietetic student placement experiences in hospital: implications for education

Abstract

Background Healthcare placements in dietetics education contribute significantly to student learning. Exploring students’ self‐conceptualisation of placement experiences may provide insights to better support learning. Self‐determination theory (SDT) has been used to seek insight into clinical and educational settings but has not yet been applied to dietetic placement learning. The present study investigated dietetics students’ reflections of key influences on placement learning experiences and their alignment with an SDT framework. Methods A post‐placement two‐stage critical incident debrief was conducted with seven successive cohorts (168 students) of dietetic undergraduate students on final placement. In debriefs, students’ anonymous themes were collected and discussed, inductively analysed, and then mapped against an SDT framework of psychological and motivational constructs. Results Nine key themes were identified that impacted upon placement experiences. Four themes related to framework constructs: (1) Supervisor (and Peer) Autonomy Support; (2) Perceived Competence; (3) Relatedness; and (4) Autonomy and Intrinsic Motivation. Non‐SDT themes were also present, including: (5) Learning Environment and Experience; as well as themes about professional behaviours and identity: (6) Teamwork and Interactions; (7) Managing Emotions and Self‐Care; (8) Dietetic Communications and Behaviours; and (9) Developing a Professional Identity. Conclusions Embedding a structured debrief in the curriculum and using a psychological motivational SDT framework to analyse themes arising can provide valuable information about the learning needs of students on placement with potential for wider application in dietetic learning and teaching and workforce employability. The current findings may have application in university curricula before and after professional placement.

Health and Wellness Projects Created by Student Pharmacists during Advanced Pharmacy Practice Experiences: Exploring the Impact on Professional Development

“…Progressing from extrinsic to intrinsic motivation, coupled with feelings of competence, relatedness, and autonomy in one’s professional role, strongly supports student PIF [ 21 , 22 ]. Thus, it is advantageous to view health professional student learning opportunities through the lens of SDT to optimize the professional development value of the experiences [ 19 , 23 ].…”

“…To assess the HWP impact on student professional development, the 12 remaining initial codes were framed as subthemes using the main SDT themes of competence, relatedness, and autonomy. Using a method from the literature used to assess the learning impact in dietetic students [ 23 ], any codes analogous to a tenet of SDT were modified toward that construct. For example, the initial theme of “student increased confidence” was modified to “perceived competence”, and the initial theme of “increased opportunity to build patient relationships” was modified to “increased opportunity to connect with patients”.…”

Relationships between ICT competencies related to work, self-esteem, and self-regulated learning with engineering competencies

“…Gupta Kriti [ 34 ] used SDT as the framework to investigate the factors underlying the adoption of massive open online courses (MOOCs). Markwell, et al [ 35 ] pointed out that constructs related to the SDT concept impact student placement, learning, and experiences. Zheng, et al [ 36 ] showed that students’ basic psychological needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness motivated them to engage actively in learning and to have better performance and academic achievements.…”

Impact of a resilience and wellbeing program: A longitudinal cohort study of student dietitians

“…By the end of the practicum, students are required to demonstrate competence for independent practice as measured against national competency standards (Dietitians Association of Australia, 2015Australia, , 2017. The practicum is an immersive experience that provides students with an opportunity to integrate theory and practice and develop the skills and attributes of a healthcare professional (Markwell et al, 2021). Students' success on their practicum is influenced by the quality of their teaching and assessment, adequate preparation for practice (Ottrey et al, 2021), and their own personal attributes (Maher et al, 2015).…”