A Skill Acquisition Perspective on the Impact of Exergaming Technology on Foundational Movement Skill Development in Children 3–12 Years: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Abstract

Background Sedentary, digital screen time in children represents a major concern due to its detrimental effect on children’s development. Nowadays, however, advances in technology allow children to actively interact with a digital screen using their whole body (e.g., exergaming), providing potential for movement learning. Exergaming technology may prove valuable in supporting children’s development of foundational movement skills (FMS). Objective To examine the impact of exergaming technology on the development of FMS in children 3–12 years through a skill acquisition lens. Methods Systematic review and meta-analysis were conducted following the PRISMA guidelines. Web of Science, PubMed, PsycINFO and SPORTDiscus databases were searched between 2007 and 2022. Studies were eligible if they conducted an exergaming intervention to improve FMS in typically developing children aged three to twelve with a control group, using a baseline and post-intervention assessment design. FMS outcomes were pooled with a random effects model. Results Nine trials (4 RCTs, 2 cluster RCTs and 3 non-randomized trials) of varying methodological quality (2 had low, 6 had some concerns, and 1 had a high risk of bias) were included, with a total of 783 participants. FMS outcome measures across studies comprised object control skills, locomotor skills, coordination, agility, balance and balance-related skills. The meta-analysis included showed a small positive effect in favor of the exergaming intervention (r = 0.24 [95% confidence interval: 0.11–0.36]). Conclusion Our results indicate that screen-based technology that requires an active engagement of the child can promote the development of FMS. Considering that FMS are the foundation of a child’s physical, mental, health and academic development, this finding could lead to a reshaping of the perception of digital screen-based technology and the role this should play in children’s lives. We speculate that the observed benefits most likely depend upon the quality of information–movement coupling specificity and the motor learning strategies built into the exergame and/or the intervention design. We do not believe this is dependent on the type of FMS being performed or the amount of practice. We recommend therefore that future research should examine how practitioners (school teachers, coaches and parents) can facilitate the interaction between a child and exergaming technology.

Acute effects of exergaming on young adults’ energy expenditure, enjoyment, and self-efficacy

“…Energy expenditure in exergaming is often compared to traditional aerobic exercise because it can provide many of the same benefits with some additional advantages ( Hwang et al, 2019 ; Çakir-Atabek et al, 2020 ; Park et al, 2020 ; Ferreira et al, 2022 ). Exergaming typically requires the user to physically engage with the game (e.g., by hopping or jumping) just like traditional aerobic exercise does ( McDonough et al, 2018 ; Oppici et al, 2022 ; Pasco and Roure, 2022 ; Sousa et al, 2022 ). This physical engagement can be seen as a form of exercise and has been shown to increase energy expenditure in some cases.…”

Comparative effectiveness of school-based exercise interventions on physical fitness in children and adolescents: a systematic review and network meta-analysis

“…Since the exercise intensity of most commercial AVGs (e.g., Xbox Kinect, Wii, PlayStation) cannot reach the minimum threshold needed to stimulate growth in muscle strength ( 27 ), it is probable that the increase in CMJ performance caused by AVGs may be related to elevated locomotor skills rather than muscle strength. Two previous reviews support this inference, revealing that AVGs had a small but statistically significant effects on the fundamental motor skills of young people ( 105 , 106 ). However, the disadvantages of AVGs are obvious as well.…”

Motor performance in children before, during and after COVID-19 pandemic and the role of socioeconomic background: A 10-year cohort study of 68,996 third grade children

“…Here, beside traditional approaches such as local school communities (e.g., Naul et al, 2018), exergaming technology could play an important role (cf. Oppici et al, 2022).…”