A study of respiration‐correlated cone‐beam CT scans to correct target positioning errors in radiotherapy of thoracic cancer

Abstract

Purpose: There is increasingly widespread usage of cone-beam CT (CBCT) for guiding radiation treatment in advanced-stage lung tumors, but difficulties associated with daily CBCT in conventionally fractionated treatments include imaging dose to the patient, increased workload and longer treatment times. Respiration-correlated cone-beam CT (RC-CBCT) can improve localization accuracy in mobile lung tumors, but further increases the time and workload for conventionally fractionated treatments. This study investigates whether RC-CBCT-guided correction of systematic tumor deviations in standard fractionated lung tumor radiation treatments is more effective than 2D imagebased correction of skeletal deviations alone. A second study goal compares respiration-correlated vs respiration-averaged images for determining tumor deviations. Methods: Eleven stage II-IV nonsmall cell lung cancer patients are enrolled in an IRB-approved prospective off-line protocol using RC-CBCT guidance to correct for systematic errors in GTV position. Patients receive a respiration-correlated planning CT (RCCT) at simulation, daily kilovoltage RC-CBCT scans during the first week of treatment and weekly scans thereafter. Four types of correction methods are compared: (1) systematic error in gross tumor volume (GTV) position, (2) systematic error in skeletal anatomy, (3) daily skeletal corrections, and (4) weekly skeletal corrections. The comparison is in terms of weighted average of the residual GTV deviations measured from the RC-CBCT scans and representing the estimated residual deviation over the treatment course. In the second study goal, GTV deviations computed from matching RCCT and RC-CBCT are compared to deviations computed from matching respiration-averaged images consisting of a CBCT reconstructed using all projections and an average-intensity-projection CT computed from the RCCT. Results: Of the eleven patients in the GTV-based systematic correction protocol, two required no correction, seven required a single correction, one required two corrections, and one required three corrections. Mean residual GTV deviation (3D distance) following GTV-based systematic correction (mean ± 1 standard deviation 4.8 ± 1.5 mm) is significantly lower than for systematic skeletal-based (6.5 ± 2.9 mm, p = 0.015), and weekly skeletal-based correction (7.2 ± 3.0 mm, p = 0.001), but is not significantly lower than daily skeletal-based correction (5.4 ± 2.6 mm, p = 0.34). In two cases, first-day CBCT images reveal tumor changes-one showing tumor growth, the other showing large tumor displacement-that are not readily observed in radiographs. Differences in computed GTV deviations between respiration-correlated and respiration-averaged images are 0.2 ± 1.8 mm in the superior-inferior direction and are of similar magnitude in the other directions. Conclusions: An off-line protocol to correct GTV-based systematic error in locally advanced lung tumor cases can be effective at reducing tumor deviations, although the findings need confirmation with larger patient s...

Predictive Treatment Management: Incorporating a Predictive Tumor Response Model Into Robust Prospective Treatment Planning for Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer

“…For this proof-of-principle study, we used the planning CT and consecutive weekly kilovoltage CBCT scans of 5 patients with locally advanced NSCLC who were enrolled in a prospective imaging protocol approved by our Institutional Review Board (12). Six other patients were in the protocol; for these, either no shrinkage was observed or tumors were not completely visualized on the CBCTs.…”

Digital tomosynthesis (DTS) for verification of target position in early stage lung cancer patients

“…We studied the agreement between target registration derived using the clinical combination of CBCT and AvIP-CT, 23 versus the combination of short arc-based DTS of the tumor region during treatment (CB-DTS) and a digitally reconstructed DTS from the AvIP-CT (Reference-DTS), both representing a temporally averaged target position, with or without triangulation. The advantage of short arc DTS + triangulation is that it facilitates faster and more frequent verification of target position.…”

Feasibility of dynamic adaptive passive scattering proton therapy with computed tomography image guidance in the lung

“…Current image‐guided PBT treatments utilize orthogonal two‐dimensional kV X‐ray images and bone registration techniques to set up the patient target volume; however, these X‐ray images do not permit the visualization of low‐contrast tumors. Many photon treatment facilities are now using CBCT and in‐room CT imaging techniques for guidance, especially for lung tumors where soft‐tissue contrast facilitates tumor visualization . Tumor registration in PBT would be one solution to improve geometric accuracy, as it would allow the location and deformation of the tumor to be known.…”

“…Many photon treatment facilities are now using CBCT and in-room CT imaging techniques for guidance, especially for lung tumors where soft-tissue contrast facilitates tumor visualization. 11 Tumor registration in PBT would be one solution to improve geometric accuracy, as it would allow the location and deformation of the tumor to be known.…”