A systematic review of pre-pandemic resilience factors and mental health outcomes in adolescents and young adults during the COVID-19 pandemic

Abstract

Background: Adolescence and young adulthood are sensitive developmental periods to environmental influences. Investigating pre-emptive measures against stressors, such as those associated with the COVID-19 pandemic, on mental health and wellbeing is crucial. We aimed to synthesise evidence on pre-pandemic resilience factors shaping youth mental health outcomes during this period. Methods: For this pre-registered systematic review, we searched seven databases for longitudinal studies of youth populations affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, assessing a-priori defined resilience factors at the individual, family, or community level before the pandemic. Studies required validated mental health or wellbeing measures collected both before and during the pandemic. Study quality was assessed using the corresponding NIH Quality Assessment Tool. Results: From 3099 unique records, 23 studies across 11 countries were included, using 39 distinct resilience measures. Factors at the individual level were explored in 13 studies, community-related in 11, and family factors in eight. Due to the heterogeneity of study designs, we applied a narrative synthesis approach, finding that resilience factors were generally associated with better mental health outcomes both prior to and during the pandemic. However, most factors did not mitigating pandemic-related mental health effects. Nonetheless, family-level resilience factors emerged as promising under specific conditions. Study quality was generally fair, with concerns in resilience assessment and sampling quality. Conclusion: Family-level resilience factors may positively impact pandemic mental health outcomes. Future research should prioritise rigorous study designs and comprehensive resilience assessments to enhance our understanding of resilience in pandemic settings and beyond.