A Systematic Review of Scientific Studies on the Effects of Music in People with Personality Disorders

Abstract

Personality Disorders (PDs) are psychiatric conditions involving maladaptive personality traits and behaviours. Previous research has shown that musical preferences and the use of music may be related to personality traits. Additionally, music therapy is increasingly being used as a treatment option for people with PDs. Using the PRISMA guidelines, a systematic literature search was undertaken using three databases: PubMed, Web of Science, and PsycInfo. The following search terms were used: PubMed: “personality disorder” AND (music OR “music therapy”); Web of Science (advanced search): TS = (personality disorder) AND TS = (music or “music therapy”); PsycInfo: “personality disorder” AND (music OR “music therapy”). A total of 24 studies were included in this review and summarised into four categories: music preference, music therapy, music performance, and music imagery, all in relation to PDs or traits associated with PDs. The analysis found that individuals with personality traits associated with PDs may prefer different types or genres of music or interact with music differently than those without these traits. Additionally, music therapy (MT) was found to offer a potentially useful treatment option for PDs. The power of these findings was limited by the small number of included studies. This review offers a useful foundation upon which further research looking at MT as a potential treatment option for PDs can be built.

Tidal Model, Mindfulness, and Music Therapy to Minimize Exacerbations of Borderline Personality Disorder

“…The questionnaire titled The Nurse's Knowledge about the Effects of the Tidal Model, Music Therapy, and Mindfulness in Reducing the Exacerbation of Symptoms of Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) Traits in Puerto Rican Women was administered to 33 participants. The instrument was administered as a pretest to explore their knowledge about the Tidal Model, Mindfulness, and Music Therapy [31][32][33][34][35][36]. It was given as a posttest to verify if they had gained the understanding that would enable them to implement the integration of the approaches.…”

Music therapy for therapeutic development in personality disorders: A qualitative case study

“…Evidence of its efficacy remains limited, however, due to small sample sizes and methodological limitations. In Haslam et al's (2022) small‐scale systematic review of 24 studies, MT was found to offer a potentially useful treatment option for PDs. The authors reported that selected music helped to reduce violence and hostility; playlists developed by patients with the support of their therapists aided in managing aggressive impulses in foreseeably difficult situations; patients can benefit from music for relaxation; and music can aid cognitive problem solving and improve mood in people with insecurities.…”

A correlation study of music training, adult attachment, and personality traits using a large-sample questionnaire

“…The past few decades have seen increasing research on the psychological aspects of music using behavioral and neural measures (De Witte et al, 2020;McCrary et al, 2022). Even in daily music activities, music training affects attachment patterns and personality characteristics because of its psychological function in arousing/regulating emotion, facilitating cognition, memory recall, and activating sensorimotor functions (Corrigall et al, 2013;Haslam et al, 2022). Correspondingly, the influence of psychological traits on music training has also attracted attention in the contexts of human interaction and human-computer interaction (Penhune, 2020;Miranda, 2021;Tsai and Liang, 2023).…”