A Systematic Review of Technology Reviews in Language Teaching and Learning Journals

Abstract

Technology reviews are a specific article genre published in several language teaching and learning journals. Their emergence is likely due to the proliferation of technology that facilitates and supports language acquisition. These reviews aim to increase teachers’ and learners’ awareness of the forms of technology available and succinctly describe their benefits and limitations for language teaching and learning. As education enters a new digital age, accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, it is essential to determine which forms of technology support teachers’ professional learning and how they can be utilized. This article presents a systematic review of technology reviews published between 2017 and 2022 in five Q1 SCOPUS-indexed language teaching and learning journals: RELC Journal, TESOL Journal, CALICO Journal, Language Learning and Technology and Teaching English as a Second Language Electronic Journal (TESL-EJ). These five journals were the only Q1 language teaching and learning journals we identified that publish technology reviews. All 73 technology reviews published in the 5-year period in the 5 journals were reviewed. Using professional digital competence as a framework, we explore what the articles reveal about how technology is used, as well as the knowledge gaps that remain. We examine the types and features of the technology described in the reviews, the language skills and educational levels of the learners, and the pedagogical implications of technology use. We found that the technology reviews mainly introduced the technological features and functions of the reviewed technologies with less emphasis placed on their pedagogical utilities and social aspects of their use for language teaching. The article concludes with recommendations for authors and journal editors regarding the content that should be included in a technology review to ensure that it is helpful to the profession. We also offer advice to practitioners on how to benefit from technology reviews.

Teaching with Technology in the Post-Pandemic Digital Age: Technological Normalisation and AI-Induced Disruptions

“…Indeed, specific digital tools require specific competencies. For this special issue, Moorhouse et al (2023) use a PDC framework to analyse technology reviews published in teaching and learning journals. In the review, the authors provide an overview of the digital tools language teachers can use in their teaching, their pedagogical affordances, and important considerations related to risk, well-being and ethics teachers should consider when deciding to use specific digital tools in their practices.…”

A lesson study on a MOOC-based and AI-powered flipped teaching and assessment of EFL writing model: teachers' and students' growth

“…In recent years, there has been an evident upsurge in the use of technologies to teach foreign languages. For language teachers, this surge has brought about a sense of promise and overwhelm in them, considering the wealth of captivating options available (Moorhouse et al, 2023). For language learners nowadays, technologies have availed rich self-learning resources and students, often referred to as the Digital Natives (Prensky, 2001), learn differently from the previous generations.…”

“…In recent years, there has been an evident upsurge in the use of technologies to teach foreign languages. For language teachers, this surge has brought about a sense of promise and overwhelm in them, considering the wealth of captivating options available (Moorhouse et al. , 2023).…”