A systematic review of working conditions and occupational health among immigrants in Europe and Canada

Abstract

BackgroundA systematic attempt to summarize the literature that examines working conditions and occupational health among immigrant in Europe and Canada.MethodsWe established inclusion criteria, searched systematically for articles included in the Medline, Embase and Social Sciences Citation Index databases in the period 2000–2016 and checked the reference lists of all included papers.ResultsEighty-two studies were included in this review; 90% were cross-sectional and 80% were based on self-report. Work injuries were consistently found to be more prevalent among immigrants in studies from different countries and in studies with different designs. The prevalence of perceived discrimination or bullying was found to be consistently higher among immigrant workers than among natives. In general, however, we found that the evidence that immigrant workers are more likely to be exposed to physical or chemical hazards and poor psychosocial working conditions is very limited. A few Scandinavian studies support the idea that occupational factors may partly contribute to the higher risk of sick leave or disability pension observed among immigrants. However, the evidence for working conditions as a potential mediator of the associations between immigrant status and poor general health and mental distress was very limited.ConclusionSome indicators suggest that immigrant workers in Europe and Canada experience poorer working conditions and occupational health than do native workers. However, the ability to draw conclusions is limited by the large gaps in the available data, heterogeneity of immigrant working populations, and the lack of prospectively designed cohort studies.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12889-018-5703-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Migrant Workers and Psychological Health: A Systematic Review

“…Sterud's study found that the risk of mental disorders was higher among people from ethnic minorities who reported receiving unfair treatment or racial slurs. However, studies in Scandinavia, Spain and Arab countries point out that difference in working conditions have a negligible impact on the increased risk of poor mental health among immigrants [25].…”

Work injuries in internal migrants to Alberta, Canada. Do workers' compensation records provide an unbiased estimate of risk?

“…Many studies have been carried out of injuries in those who have moved to another country to work, as permanent residents, seasonal contracted employees or as legal or undocumented immigrants, most (for example) but not all find immigrant workers to be at greater risk of workplace injury. Studies not finding an excess have largely been those comparing migrant and local workers in the same work or migrants who have come to skilled jobs or have been settled in the host country over many years .…”

Discourse on culture in research on immigrant and migrant workers’ health

“…Furthermore, the lack of theoretical frameworks about the underlying causes of inequalities between foreign and native‐born workers, and the scarcity of research on the role of culture specifically, means that mechanisms and pathways are only superficially understood . Evidence suggests that there are large gaps in the available data on all potential mechanisms for health and safety inequalities by immigrant or migrant status, including working conditions . Given the increasing diversity of the labor force and widening social inequalities, there is a need for occupational health research to develop an understanding of the social, economic, technical, and political drivers of immigrant and migrant workers’ health .…”