Bacteremia, a systemic infection associated with severe clinical outcomes, is often caused by Gram-negative facultative anaerobes. ArcAB, a two-component regulatory system that represses aerobic respiration, is a key mediator of metabolic adaptation for such bacteria. Using targeted mutational analysis informed by global genetic screens, we identified thearcAgene as promoting fitness ofKlebsiella pneumoniae,Citrobacter freundii, andSerratia marcescensbut notEscherichia coliin a murine model of bacteremia. Engineered mutants lackingarcAexhibit a dysregulated response to changes in oxygen availability, iron limitation, and membrane perturbations, all of which bacterial cells experience during infection. The genetic response of thearcAmutants relative to wild-type strains to the cationic antimicrobial peptide polymyxin B demonstrates an expanded role for ArcA as an activator in response to membrane damage in addition to metabolic adaptation. ArcA function is furthermore linked to electron transport chain activity based on its response to uncoupling of proton motive force by carbonyl cyanide-m-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP). Differences in lactate and acetate levels as well as lactate dehydrogenase activity between arcA mutant and wild-type cells following CCCP treatment establish an ArcA-mediated shift to fermentation independent of oxygen availability. This study highlights the semi-conserved role of ArcA during bacteremia and consolidates infection phenotypes into a comprehensive model based on respiratory activity.