A Tale of Integration? The Migrant Wealth Gap in Austria

Abstract

We investigate how previous generations of migrants and their children integrated into Austrian society, as measured by their wealth ownership. Using individual-level data from the Household Finance and Consumption Survey (HFCS), we document (1) a positive average migrant wealth gap between migrants and natives—that is, migrants owning less wealth than natives, especially in the upper half of the distribution, (2) substantial within-group inequality for migrants, and (3) evidence for catch-up, since second-generation migrants are much more similar to natives in terms of wealth and socio-economic characteristics than first-generation migrants. Using a RIF regression, we confirm an economically significant migrant wealth gap for first-generation migrants after controlling for socio-economic characteristics especially for the upper middle of the distribution, where housing wealth is a particularly relevant asset category. Second-generation migrants’ wealth gap is fully explained by our covariates in the middle of the distribution, whereas at the top where business wealth is more salient, their characteristics predict them to have higher wealth than natives. Decomposing the partial effects of covariates suggests that inheritances have the highest explanatory power for the migrant wealth gap of both first- and second-generation migrants, further buttressing the case for progressive integration in terms of wealth, while the composition of the migrant population, and in particular migrants’ heritage may continue to play a role in their wealth ownership.

Estimating the Wage Premia of Refugee Immigrants: Lessons from Sweden

“…Using data from the period 1992-2018, he showed that the wage gap is largely explained by natives specializing in high-paying interactive activities between and within occupations, whereas foreign workers are specializing in low-paying manual activities. Muckenhuber, Rehm, and Schnetzer (2022) used a sample of Austrian household data for 2014 to investigate the native-migrant wealth gap as an indicator of integration into society. Controlling for socioeconomic characteristics, they found that the gap is most pronounced especially in the upper half of the distribution, with substantial within-group inequality for migrants and evidence for catching up when second-generation migrants are considered.…”

Wages and working conditions of non-Irish nationals in Ireland

“…pay), compared to Slovakia where migrants actually earn 12.6 per cent more than non-migrants (mean hourly pay) (Amo-Agyei, 2020). Secondly, there is variation in the hourly wage gap depending on where migrants are along the wage distribution (Barrett, et al, 2012;Muckenhuber et al, 2022). In some countries (e.g., Austria and Cyprus), the wage gap appears largest at the lower (less well-paid) deciles of the distribution.…”

Economic and labour market impacts of migration in Austria: an agent-based modelling approach

“…Austria, as well as most other advanced economies, has repeatedly experienced large waves of migration (Fassmann & Münz, 1995 ). In recent history, several events have led to an increase in migration flows to Austria: the Gastarbeiter (guest workers) policy in the 1970s implemented to counteract the lack of workers, which led to migration from Turkey and Yugoslavia; the fall of the Iron Curtain, which steered an increase in migration from central European countries and Yugoslavia, along with the Bosnian war (Jestl et al, 2022 ; Muckenhuber et al, 2022 ; Rupnow, 2017 ). In 1995, when Austria became a member of the European Union, migration increased the share of EU citizens, especially from Germany (Goujon & Bauer, 2015 ).…”