The rational design of molecular photonic devices
requires a thorough understanding of all factors affecting
electronic communication among the various constituents. To
explore how electronic factors mediate both excited-
and ground-state electronic communication in multiporphyrin arrays, we
have conducted a detailed static spectroscopic
(absorption, fluorescence, resonance Raman, electron paramagnetic
resonance), time-resolved spectroscopic (absorption,
fluorescence), and electrochemical (cyclic and square-wave voltammetry,
coulometry) study of tetraarylporphyrin
dimers. The complexes investigated include both zinc-free base
(ZnFb) and bis-Zn dimers in which the porphyrin
constituents are linked via diphenylethyne groups at the
meso positions. Comparison of dimeric arrays
containing
pentafluorophenyl groups at all nonlinking meso positions
(F30ZnFbU and F30Zn2U)
with nonfluorinated analogs
(ZnFbU and Zn2U) directly probes the effects of electronic
factors on intradimer communication. The major
findings
of the study are as follows: (1) Energy transfer from the
photoexcited Zn porphyrin to the Fb porphyrin is the
predominant excited-state reaction in F30ZnFbU, as is
also the case for ZnFbU. Energy transfer primarily
proceeds
via a through-bond process mediated by the diarylethyne linker.
Remarkably, the energy-transfer rate is 10 times
slower in F30ZnFbU ((240
ps)-1) than in ZnFbU ((24
ps)-1), despite the fact that each has the
same diphenylethyne
linker. The attenuated energy-transfer rate in the former dimer is
attributed to reduced Q-excited-state electronic
coupling between the Zn and Fb porphyrins. (2) The rate of
hole/electron hopping in the monooxidized bis-Zn
complex, [F30Zn2U]+, is
∼10-fold slower than that for [Zn2U]+.
The slower hole/electron hopping rate in the former
dimer reflects strongly attenuated ground-state electronic coupling.
The large attenuation in excited- and ground-state electronic communication observed for the fluorine-containing
dimers is attributed to a diminution in the electron-exchange matrix elements that stems from stabilization of the
a2u porphyrin orbital combined with changes in
the
electron-density distribution in this orbital. Stabilization of
the porphyrin a2u orbital results in a switch in the
HOMO
from a2u in ZnFbU to a1u in
F30ZnFbU. This orbital reversal diminishes the
electron density at the peripheral positions
where the linker is appended. Collectively, our studies clarify
the origin of the different energy-transfer rates observed
among various multiporphyrin arrays and exemplify the interconnected
critical roles of a1u/a2u orbital ordering
and
linker position in the design of efficient molecular photonic
devices.