A Twitter-Lived Red Tide Crisis on Chiloé Island, Chile: What Can Be Obtained for Social-Ecological Research through Social Media Analysis?

Abstract

Considering traditional research on social-ecological crises, new social media analysis, particularly Twitter data, contributes with supplementary exploration techniques. In this article, we argue that a social media approach to social-ecological crises can offer an actor-centered meaningful perspective on social facts, a depiction of the general dynamics of meaning making that takes place among actors, and a systemic view of actors’ communication before, during and after the crisis. On the basis of a multi-technique approach to Twitter data (TF-IDF, hierarchical clustering, egocentric networks and principal component analysis) applied to a red tide crisis on Chiloé Island, Chile, in 2016, the most significant red tide in South America ever, we offer a view on the boundaries and dynamics of meaning making in a social-ecological crisis. We conclude that this dynamics shows a permanent reflexive work on elucidating the causes and effects of the crisis that develops according to actors’ commitments, the sequence of events, and political conveniences. In this vein, social media analysis does not replace good qualitative research, it rather opens up supplementary possibilities for capturing meanings from the past that cannot be retrieved otherwise. This is particularly relevant for studying social-ecological crises and supporting collective learning processes that point towards increased resilience capacities and more sustainable trajectories in affected communities.

Collective capabilities shape the co-production of nature’s contributions to people in the alpine agricultural system of the Maurienne valley, France

“…However, manual coding limits the transferability of our method to other contexts, as a profound familiarisation with the dataset precedes manual coding. Data mining tools offer promising avenues for future, more sensitive coding of themes for sentiment analysis (Liu and Zhang 2012;Hale et al 2019;Mascareño et al 2020).…”

Exploring Negative Spillover Effects on Stakeholders: A Case Study on Social Media Talk about Crisis in the Food Industry Using Data Mining

“…Social media can be a valuable tool to examine communication dynamics of stakeholders, regarding the under-crisis organization [3] and created new opportunities to study crisis-related communication [3][4][5][6][7][8][9]. These social-media based studies are referred to as "crisis informatics" [10], "social-mediated dialogue", or "social-mediated crisis communication" research [4].…”

Using Localized Twitter Activity for Red Tide Impact Assessment

“…political elections, other environmental disasters, etc)? It will be falling more in line with the research work done on public's perception of red tide (Kuhar et al, 2009, Nierenberg et al, 2010, Kirkpatrick et al, 2014 and social dynamics throughout the event (Mascareño et al, 2020). Moreover, as an alternative to relying solely on geo-tag and user geoprofile information, we plan on utilizing tweets matched to a particular location via explicit mention of that locale in the tweet content.…”