A Virtual Reality Simulation Curriculum for Intravenous Cannulation Training

Abstract

Objectives: Although virtual reality (VR) simulators play an important role in modern medical training, their efficacy is not often evaluated using learning curves. In this study, the learning curves of novice and intermediate users were elicited during a VR simulation-based curriculum for intravenous (IV) cannulation.Methods: This was a prospective observational study of subjects undergoing training using a VR model of IV cannulation. Participants were divided into two groups: novices (third-year medical students with no prior practical experience in IV catheterization) and intermediates (recent graduates with limited experience). Performance was measured with two endpoints: time to completion and errors committed. Errors were categorized as critical or noncritical. Learning curves (error score and time completion vs. session number) were analyzed using the Friedman's test. Performance before and after training was compared using the Kruskal-Wallis test. The Spearman rank correlation coefficient (r s ) was used to determine the correlation between time completion and error score estimates. The number of attempts required to complete the training phase was also measured and compared between the two groups.Results: Thirty subjects were enrolled: 17 in the novice group and 13 in the intermediate group. Learning curve plateaus of intermediates were reached in the sixth case scenario (session), whereas novices reached a plateau in the eighth session. Performance comparison of time to completion and errors showed significant improvement for both groups. Less time and fewer attempts were required by all trainees to complete a scenario while progressing through the curriculum. The overall number of IV cannulation attempts of novices was significantly higher than that of the intermediates throughout the course.Conclusions: Significant learning curves for novice and intermediate students were demonstrated after following the VR simulation-based curriculum. Competencies acquired during this educational course may provide an important advantage for training prior to actual clinical practice.

Critical Appraisal of Emergency Medicine Educational Research: The Best Publications of 2010

“…A total of 329 papers satisfied the search inclusion criteria. Forty‐one papers 7–47 survived the exclusion criteria and were scored by each of five reviewers, with a range of scores from 9.25 to 22.75. Five papers that met a priori criteria and had a mean rank of at least seven were considered methodologically superior and are highlighted for review.…”

“…Franc‐Law et al 16 showed that medical students could perform disaster triage more effectively when trained using simulation instead of conventional methods, while Ten Eyck et al 40 demonstrated that students could effectively serve as team leaders in simulated disasters when training in a simulated environment. Both Loukas et al 26 and Mallin et al 27 demonstrated an improvement in their learners to gain vascular access on a simulator. Pediatric EM fellows favorably reviewed a simulation‐based curriculum in acute care; 12 medical students demonstrated improved performance in managing emergency situations on an observed structured clinical examination (OSCE) evaluation; 35 and critical care nurses retained their skills in securing a difficult airway on a simulator 1 month after training 41 .…”

“…As in past years, research involving the use of technology accounted for a significant number of publications (34%), including 60% of the highlighted studies. Simulation (22%) 8,12,16,21,26,27,35,40,41 and ultrasound (15%) 7,13,26,27,39,44 were the technologies employed. As in past years, simulation was chosen to teach and evaluate critical events, especially those that occur infrequently in daily practice, or to introduce inexperienced learners to advanced topics.…”

Long-Term Skills Retention Following a Randomized Prospective Trial on Adaptive Procedural Training

“…Notable advantages to using CuSum in medical school education and surgical training is its ability to depict individual participant learning curves and its high sensitivity to detect variations in performance including relapses in proficiency over time. 9–11 …”

Virtual reality in anesthesia "simulation"

“…Starting off with one of the simplest procedure of intravenous cannulation for an intern[78] to a challenging surgery[910] nowadays can be learnt without experimenting on a patient. The literature is replete with studies proving that how learning on simulators prepares the intern to become better resident.…”