OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether a responsive stimulation intervention delivered to caregivers of young children either alone or integrated with nutrition interventions would benefit parenting skills and emotional availability to promote children's development and growth compared with either a nutrition intervention alone or the usual standard of care.METHODS: A cluster randomized factorial effectiveness trial was implemented in an impoverished community in Pakistan. The 4 trial arms were control (usual standard of care), responsive stimulation (responsive care and stimulation), enhanced nutrition (education and multiple micronutrients), and a combination of both enriched interventions. The 4 intervention packages were delivered by community health workers to 1489 mother-infant dyads in the first 2 years of life. Parenting skills and emotional availability indexed by mother-child interaction, caregiving environment, knowledge and practices pertaining to early childhood care and feeding, and maternal depressive symptoms were assessed at multiple intervals. An intention-to-treat factorial analysis was conducted.RESULTS: Intervention groups were comparable at baseline. Responsive stimulation significantly benefitted parenting skills with large effect sizes on mother-child interaction (Cohen's d 0.8), caregiving environment (Cohen's d 0.9-1.0), and knowledge and practices (Cohen's d 0.7-1.1) compared with small-modest significant effects as a result of nutrition intervention on mother-child interaction and caregiving environment only (Cohen's d 0.4 and 0.2, respectively). The combined intervention had a small significant effect on decreasing maternal depressive symptoms over time (Cohen's d 0-0.2).CONCLUSIONS: A responsive stimulation intervention can promote positive caregiving behaviors among impoverished families. Additional research is needed on interventions to reduce maternal depressive symptoms.
WHAT'S KNOWN ON THIS SUBJECT:Early parenting programs benefit children' s development in low-and middle-income countries. However, the extent to which these interventions have a positive impact on parenting skills and their emotional availability is less studied.
WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS:An early child development intervention using play and communication activities to promote caregivers' responsiveness can improve mother-child interactions, caregiving environment, caregiving practices pertaining to development and feeding, and, in combination with a nutrition intervention, support maternal emotional well-being. Dr Yousafzai conceptualized the study; developed the protocol, study design, and data collection instruments; coordinated the implementation of the study and oversaw training of the research team; planned analysis; interpreted findings; and drafted the manuscript; Ms Rasheed trained the Community-based Child Development Assessors, oversaw quality assurance of the psychosocial evaluations, contributed to the review of literature, contributed to the interpretation of findings, and critically reviewed draft...