About the Equivalence of the Latent D-Scoring Model and the Two-Parameter Logistic Item Response Model

Abstract

This article shows that the recently proposed latent D-scoring model of Dimitrov is statistically equivalent to the two-parameter logistic item response model. An analytical derivation and a numerical illustration are employed for demonstrating this finding. Hence, estimation techniques for the two-parameter logistic model can be used for estimating the latent D-scoring model. In an empirical example using PISA data, differences of country ranks are investigated when using different metrics for the latent trait. In the example, the choice of the latent trait metric matters for the ranking of countries. Finally, it is argued that an item response model with bounded latent trait values like the latent D-scoring model might have advantages for reporting results in terms of interpretation.

The Response Vector for Mastery Method of Standard Setting

“…As a side note, as shown by Robitzsch (2021), the latent RFM2 model in Equation 1 is theoretically equivalent (at population level) to the two-parameter logistic (2PL) model in IRT (e.g., Hambleton et al, 1991) bounded to the scale interval [0-1]; (at sample level, however, the 2PL realization of the RFM2 is complicated by practically inconvenient restrictions).…”

To Check or Not to Check? A Comment on the Contemporary Psychometrics (ConPsy) Checklist for the Analysis of Questionnaire Items

“…The latent normality assumption in ordinal FA is, unfortunately, often taken for granted, but it can be tested [18]. More flexible distributions could be identified from data (e.g., [19]). However, such a data-driven approach remains atheoretical, and it is questionable whether measurement models with more flexibly estimated distributions would be more appropriate and provide more valid results.…”