In search for new examples of absolute asymmetric synthesis (AAS), chiral α‐substituted benzyllithium complexes have been prepared. While [Li(phet)(pmdta)] (1) (phet = 1‐phenylethyl, pmdta = N,N,N′,N″,N″‐pentamethyldiethylenetriamine) affords only racemic crystals, a promising candidate for AAS was indeed found: [Li(phet)(tmpda)], α‐2, (tmpda = N,N,N′,N′‐tetramethylpropylenediamine) crystallises as a conglomerate. Although concomitant polymorphism was not observed, a racemic phase (β‐2) could also be isolated. Chiral crystals of α‐2 gave 2‐phenylpropionic acid in high yield on reaction with gaseous CO2, but the bulk product was racemic. It is unclear whether the lack of selectivity originates during crystallisation or carbonation. In order to investigate this, similar complexes displaying Si or S atoms in the α‐position were prepared and structurally characterized: [Li(tmsb)(tmpda)] (tmsb = 1‐trimetylsilylbenzyl) (3), [Li{C(CH3)(Ph)(SPh)}(pmdta)] (4), [Li{C(CH3)(Ph)(SPh)}(tmeda)] (5), and [Li(tmeda)2][C(CH3)(Ph)(SPh)] (6). The introduction of heavy atoms should allow determination of absolute configuration and enantiopurity, but so far only racemic crystals have been obtained.