“…17 shows only those ArchaeanProterozoic VDM data that passed a criteria of Macouin et al (2006), including a double heating technique with pTRM checks. Macouin et al (2006) together with results from this study. The summarized data are from Morimoto et al (1997), Yoshihara & Hamano (2000, , Sumita et al (2001), Yu & Dunlop (2001, 2002; Smirov et al (2003), Macouin et al (2003), Halls et al (2004), Macouin et al (2006), McArde et al (2004), Thomas & Piper (1995) and Biggin et al (2009).…”