“…The nonlinear magnetic response of the superconductor when flux pinning is present, is reflected in the presence of higher harmonics. Great efforts have been made to understand the physics implied in these harmonics not only for superconductors in bulk [12,13,14,15,16,17,18] but also for superconducting thin films [9,19]. The third harmonic χ 3 has shown to be an indicative of flux penetration into the sample and has been embraced as a criterion for the determination of the critical current density J c [5,6,7,9].…”