Affinity law teaches that when the rotating speed of the electric submersible pump (ESP) pump is tripled, the flow rate triples and the head increases to nine times the original pump. Thus, a high-speed ESP has the potential of delivering increased production at deeper setting depths and opportunity for shorter equipment allowing operators to land the equipment in shorter tangent sections. Operation at high-speed also presents additional challenges with one of the most significant being increased potential for abrasive and erosive wear. This study compares pump performance from slurry testing to help evaluate the potential trade-offs system performance versus wear when operating at higher speeds.
When deploying ESPs in sandy applications, sand particles can enter the seal clearance between impeller and diffuser creating 3-body abrasion wear. Meanwhile, the 2-body erosion wear in stage flow path reshapes the hydraulic geometry and causes additional losses. Both abrasion and erosion cause pump head reduction, efficiency deterioration, and thrust increase. Data was collected during slurry testing for comparison of performance over the test period. The in situ head change and thrust change were monitored during the slurry test. Pre and posttest stage dimensional data were gathered for comparison. Sand samples were gathered and analyzed to ensure similar slurry conditions applied to all the tested pumps.
Slurry testing and analysis for the evaluation of ESP pump stage performance deterioration for a stage operated at 10,000 RPM as compared to a stage operated at 3,500 RPM will be provided. The pump performance degradation and dimensional wear were compared. This demonstrates higher speed ESP pump components can be created that show similar abrasive wear performance to current ESP pump.
A 10,000 rpm ESP pump completed slurry testing while measuring pressure, temperature, flow and thrust. The results provide pump performance deterioration trend in a sand application and helps to understand physics of stage wear mechanism. This is the first of this type of testing apparatus to authors’ knowledge. It also serves as a backbone in high-speed pump validation program.