Acceptability of a Health Care App With 3 User Interfaces for Older Adults and Their Caregivers: Design and Evaluation Study

Abstract

Background The older population needs solutions for independent living and reducing the burden on caregivers while maintaining the quality and dignity of life. Objective The aim of this study was to design, develop, and evaluate an older adult health care app that supports trained caregivers (ie, formal caregivers) and relatives (ie, informal caregivers). We aimed to identify the factors that affect user acceptance of interfaces depending on the user’s role. Methods We designed and developed an app with 3 user interfaces that enable remote sensing of an older adult’s daily activities and behaviors. We conducted user evaluations (N=25) with older adults and their formal and informal caregivers to obtain an overall impression of the health care monitoring app in terms of user experience and usability. In our design study, the participants had firsthand experience with our app, followed by a questionnaire and individual interview to express their opinions on the app. Through the interview, we also identified their views on each user interface and interaction modality to identify the relationship between the user’s role and their acceptance of a particular interface. The questionnaire answers were statistically analyzed, and we coded the interview answers based on keywords related to a participant’s experience, for example, ease of use and usefulness. Results We obtained overall positive results in the user evaluation of our app regarding key aspects such as efficiency, perspicuity, dependability, stimulation, and novelty, with an average between 1.74 (SD 1.02) and 2.18 (SD 0.93) on a scale of −3.0 to 3.0. The overall impression of our app was favorable, and we identified that “simple” and “intuitive” were the main factors affecting older adults’ and caregivers’ preference for the user interface and interaction modality. We also identified a positive user acceptance of the use of augmented reality by 91% (10/11) of the older adults to share information with their formal and informal caregivers. Conclusions To address the need for a study to evaluate the user experience and user acceptance by older adults as well as both formal and informal caregivers regarding the user interfaces with multimodal interaction in the context of health monitoring, we designed, developed, and conducted user evaluations with the target user groups. Our results through this design study show important implications for designing future health monitoring apps with multiple interaction modalities and intuitive user interfaces in the older adult health care domain.

Tailored Self-Management App to Support Older Adults With Cancer and Multimorbidity: Development and Usability Testing

“…The app developed in this study provides direction and guidance on how to report symptoms, events, and daily emotional states and provides an easy display to integrate these various inputs and share insights with health care providers. Unlike existing mobile apps with several views on multiple interfaces [ 46 - 48 ], this app provides a single view of all symptoms, events, and emotions consolidated on 1 page which aims to improve usability, efficiency, and satisfaction among users. The design also allows an effective presentation of daily reports in a comprehensive and easy-to-understand manner.…”

User Interface Characteristics Influencing Medical Self-Service Terminals Behavioral Intention and Acceptance by Chinese Elderly: An Empirical Examination Based on an Extended UTAUT Model

“…Tsai et al utilized Nielsen's heuristics to elucidate the usability of UI design and applied ISO 9241-11 standards to assess the usability and acceptability of an exergame system among 101 older adults, finding a robust correlation between interface design and system usability [30]. Kim et al identified that "simple" and "intuitive" UI language significantly influences elderly users' preferences for interfaces and interaction methods, aligning with the views presented in [31]. Amid the pandemic, Hamid Reza Saeidnia et al assessed smartphone app UIs tailored for the elderly, emphasizing the importance of customized design [32].…”

“…In the next place, the confirmed Hypothesis 2 (H2) underscores the importance of user-friendliness in MST interactions. To improve the interface's learnability and usability, simplifying the information delivery process is crucial [31,45]. Moreover, optimizing UID proves more effective in enhancing older adults' BI than other strategies like increasing motivation.…”

Scoping Review of Technological Solutions for Community Dwelling Older Adults and Implications for Instrumental Activities of Daily Living

“…All studies with safety monitoring (n=8) used sensors for monitoring and follow up the older adults for any dangerous cases [81,98,128], sleep monitoring [132,133], fall detection [136] and producing alerts [74,134].…”