In Experiment 1, normal lO-yr.-olds and lO-yr.-olds diagnosed as learning disabled (LD) were presented with items in visual and auditory modalities for free and cued recall. The LD children had deficits in auditory and/or visual memory. Recall by LD children was worse than for nonimpaired peers only on tasks in the impaired modality, and on cued recall the deficit was confined to recall given a semantic category cue: Recall given perceptual cues was unimpaired. In Experiment 2, presentation-time tasks were used to create a bias toward either perceptual or semantic encoding. The semantic-encoding task removed the modality-specific deficit between LD children and controls. We conclude that deficits in semantically cued recall for children with only one impaired modality had their origins at presentation time. The most parsimonious explanation of these results involves separate pathways linking the auditory and visual modalities to the semantic system.A recurring theme in the history of cognitive psychology has been the attempt to identify functionally distinct units within human mental functioning. The "faculties" of the preexperimental era, the "black boxes" of Broadbent (1958), and the "isolable subsystems" of Posner (1973) represent successive approaches to this problem. Consistently, one empirical method for carrying out this kind of analysis has been to make use of clinical subpopulations on the assumption that if a functional unitThe authors would like to thank Roberta Klatzky for her critical comments on earlier drafts of this article. The authors gratefully acknowledge the cooperation of the staff and children enrolled in the Regional Intensive Learning Centers of New Castle County, Delaware, and especially the director, E.N. Turnberger, for his generous assistance throughout all phases of this research. Ginny Jacobson and Karen MacKichan helped in the preparation of stimulus materials and collection of data, and Shirley Bakken assisted in the preparation of this manuscript.Requests for reprints should be sent to S.