Acclimatizing nuclear? Climate change, nuclear power and the reframing of risk in the UK news media

Abstract

In January 2008, the UK Labour government announced that new nuclear power would play a role in the generation of low carbon electricity, and thus in the mitigation of climate change. This reframing of new nuclear power as a means of tackling climate change signalled a dramatic U-turn on Labour’s commitment to decommission all existing UK nuclear power stations by 2025. In the context of the political reframing of new nuclear builds, this article examines how the UK news media contributed to the reframing of nuclear power as low carbon, and the implications this has for public under- standing of nuclear power and climate change. Covering the time period from September 2005 to January 2008, a critical discourse analysis of three UK newspapers – the Daily Mirror (tabloid), the Daily Mail (mid-range) and The Independent (broadsheet) – is pre- sented. This period covers the months leading up to the launch of the UK government’s first Energy Review in January 2006, to the publication of the government’s final White Paper on Nuclear Power in January 2008. The analysis found that the official governmental discourse on nuclear power as essential to climate change mitigation and the security of future energy supplies was variously reproduced and contested across the three news- papers. However, while the government’s rebranding of nuclear as less risky than climate change is not explicitly endorsed by any of the newspapers, it certainly provides the dis- cursive context through which policy decisions on new nuclear have been largely accepted by the UK news media

The role of narratives in socio-technical transitions—Fukushima and the energy regimes of Japan, Germany, and the United Kingdom

“…In 2008 the UK government announced the assigning of a central role to nuclear power in transforming the power sector. The UK media actively contributed to reframing nuclear power as a climate friendly technology (Doyle, 2011).…”

Visualizing the Paris Climate Talks on Twitter: Media and Climate Stakeholder Visual Social Media During COP21

“…Since then, media coverage of climate change has improved, with a shift from occasional to routine coverage of climate issues and reporting that contextualizes opposing viewpoints (Brüggemann, 2017). Understandably, several studies of climate change media coverage have focused on how policy solutions are portrayed by the media (Doyle, 2011;Liu, Robinson, & Vedlitz, 2016).…”

Destabilizing Environmentalism: Epiphanal Change and the Emergence of Pro-Nuclear Environmentalism

“…A greater proportion of nuclear electricity in the future energy mix is supported by all leading political parties (with the exception of the Green Party), partly on the environmental grounds that it is 'low-carbon' but more reliable than wind and solar power, the principal renewable alternatives favoured by most environmentalists. The climate change argument has a long pedigree in Britain, having been introduced by Conservative Prime Minister Thatcher in 1988 (Doyle, 2011). However, it was a Labour government that committed Britain to a new generation of nuclear power stations (BERR, 2008) after the long post-Chernobyl hiatus.…”