Accountants’ perceptions of corporate governance in public limited liability companies in an emerging economy

Abstract

Purpose – This paper aims to examine the perceptions of accountants on corporate governance (CG) practices in public limited liability companies in Barbados, and the perceived effectiveness of these mechanisms. Design/methodology/approach – A three-stage approach was utilized. First, an Internet-based questionnaire was sent to members of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Barbados to gain accounting perspectives on CG practices by listed Barbadian companies. Second, feedback on the survey results was obtained from the attendees of a panel session at a regional accounting conference. Third, interviews were conducted with five qualified accountants to further explore issues that emerged from the previous stages. Findings – The results suggest that the most important mechanisms for effective CG were the board of directors, auditors and professional accountants. The timely provision of relevant information, board room culture, qualifications and independence of directors were the tasks considered most vital to enhancing board effectiveness. However, the high concentration of ownership in family-controlled firms, interlocking directorates, weak regulatory systems and cultural issues influenced the effectiveness of CG mechanisms. Recommendations for overcoming these barriers and improving CG included purposive training, whistle-blowing mechanisms, stronger legislation and adequate disclosures. Research limitations/implications – The study’s small sample increases the likelihood of bias and important differences being missed, thus reducing the generalizability to the accounting profession as a whole. Practical implications – The research sheds light on the value being placed on CG practices by the accounting profession. The study would assist companies, board of directors and accounting practitioners in developing CG mechanisms that are suitable for emerging countries. Originality/value – The paper contributes to the dearth of literature on perceptions of accountants on CG practices in emerging economies.

Earnings management through loss Avoidance: Does South Africa have a good story to tell?

“…It is, however, possible that analysts and investors in SA pay particular attention to other performance indicators, such as revenue and headline earnings per share (which is regulatory disclosure requirement unique to SA). The difference may also be attributable to the crucial strides that have been made globally in corporate governance consciousness since the dawn of the major accounting scandals (Alleyne, Weekes-Marshall & Broome, 2014). Lastly, within the research design, the earnings and change in earnings variables have not been adjusted for the asymmetric effects of negative special items and the applicable effective tax rates for profit and loss companies, owing to data constraints.…”

Corporate governance and firm performance in an emerging market: Evidence from Barbados

“…Therefore, corporate governance disclosures of listed companies are voluntary. Meanwhile, major issues of corporate governance in Barbados include the lack of a formal governance framework, interlocking directorships and a bias in the selection of individuals to serve on various boards (Alleyne et al, 2014).…”

“…In the Caribbean, there were similar occurrences of failures and collapses of companies that promoted unethical behaviour. For example, the failure of CLICO and the collapse of the Allen Stanford Empire in Antigua for engaging in a Ponzi scheme caused attention to be focused on bad management practices which resulted in financial burdens being placed on governments and investors within the region (Alleyne et al, 2014).…”

“…In the Caribbean, corporate governance studies have been limited to empirical research focusing mainly in the area of audit committees (e.g. Alleyne et al, 2014). Although many studies have investigated the relationship between corporate governance and firm performance in developed contexts (e.g.…”

The role of internal audit in the risk management process: A developing economy perspective

“…Research in these areas should be of interest to international communities as trading partners to these entities, and hence, the collapse of large regional companies such as CL Financial Holdings, Colonial Life Insurance Company (CLICO), and the Stanford Group of Companies have all shown that there is a need to research existing models of CG and RM practices in developing economies. Barbados is highly under‐researched in these areas with only a few studies focusing on accountant's perceptions of CG (Alleyne, Weekes‐Marshall, & Broome, 2014); audit committees (Alleyne, Howard, & Greenidge, 2006); external audit (Alleyne, Devonish, & Alleyne, 2006; Alleyne & Howard, 2005). Regional RM failures were examined by Soverall (2012), while Wood and Kellman (2013) examined RM practices in Barbadian banks.…”