Accounting as capital and doxa: exploring power and resistance in World Bank projects in Tonga

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to explore the fluid role of accounting both as a form of power and resistance in the context of World Bank projects in the Island Kingdom of Tonga. Design/methodology/approach Bourdieu’s concepts of doxa and capital provided the framework for problematizing the fluidity of practices of accounting as both a form of power and of resistance. The authors used a qualitative field study design based on a combination of a documentary analysis of these loan agreements and interviews with key actors and informants. Findings The role of accounting in relation to subaltern groups is mediated by the doxic rules and existing capital arrangements at the national and the local or village level. Understanding accounting as both capital and as doxa explains why it can be both a form of power and of resistance. Practical implications This study provides policy makers and foreign donors of Tonga and other Pacific Islands a deeper understanding on the struggles to implement and the impacts of accounting at local level as accounting is deployed as part of struggles in various social contexts each with its own doxa and capital arrangements. Originality/value This study contributes to the growing accounting body of work that seeks to better understand accounting by proposing that role of accounting as a tool for domination is mediated in various social settings by the doxic value and the existing capital arrangements in those settings.

Shaping accountability at an NGO: a Bourdieusian perspective

“…However, in other senses (e.g. financially) academics may have little capital (Bourdieu, 1998, p. 5; Fukofuka and Jacobs, 2018, p. 611). Compositions of capital need to be considered not just at a fixed point in time, but as trajectories within the field that leads to dominance (Emirbayer and Johnson, 2008, pp.…”

Progress towards sustainable urban water management in Ghana

“…This is particularly the case in the steering of water management in developing countries, which continue to be beholden to the requirements of key external financiers such as the World Bank. Fukofuka and Jacobs (2018) observe in the case of Tongan development projects, however, that while the World Bank tends to dominate at the time contracts are signed, that relationship becomes more complex as those projects progress, with national and even village level actors able to forge an influence.…”

Sistemas De Controle Gerencial Como Instrumento De Poder Sob a Ótica De Bourdieu

“…No entanto, identificou-se que tais estudos não abordam o fenômeno estudado em profundidade, principalmente no que concerne à área de Contabilidade Gerencial e à utilização de todos os elementos do referencial teórico-analítico de Bourdieu, o que vai ao encontro dos achados de Vogt et al (2019). Adicionalmente, a ausência de pesquisas sobre os aspectos do poder da contabilidade também pode ocorrer justamente porque a contabilidade é aceita tacitamente pela sociedade (Fukofuka & Jacobs, 2018).…”

“…Outra justificativa decorre de Malmi e Brown (2008), os quais sugerem que existe dificuldade em se operacionalizar estudos que envolvam uma variedade de SCG. Ademais, há uma baixa variedade de temática nas pesquisas em Contabilidade (Homero, 2017), sendo que a temática poder ainda é considerada incipiente nessa área no âmbito nacional (Mendonça, Cardoso, Riccio, & Sakata, 2008;Cosenza, Teixeira Filho, & Lopes, 2012;Macohon & Lavarda, 2015) e internacional (Fukofuka & Jacobs, 2018). Alguns estudos negligenciam a utilização conjunta dos conceitos chaves de Bourdieu (Macintosh & Quattrone, 2010;Vogt et al, 2019).…”