Accounting as rhetorical devices during the COVID-19 pandemic: evidence from Australian universities

Abstract

PurposeThis paper has two purposes. First, it aims to explore how Australian universities used calculative rhetoric and practices through accounting numbers to persuade employees and legitimize their financial recovery plans to alleviate the financial hardship caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Second, it aims to analyze how the accounting-based solutions were legitimized through a well-blended pathos, logos and ethos rhetoric.Design/methodology/approachBuilding on a rhetorical theory of diffusion, we employed a qualitative research design within all 37 Australian public universities involving Internet-based documentary analysis.FindingsThis study finds that in an urgent crisis like the fiscal crisis caused by COVID-19, universities again found rescue in accounting tools, in particular budgets, as a rhetorical device to justify their operational and strategic choices such as job-cuts, programs closures and staff pay-cuts. However, in this crisis, the same old accounting-based solutions were even more quickly to be accepted by being delivered in management’s colorful blending of pathos–logos–ethos rhetoric.Research limitations/implicationsWhile this study is constrained to Australian public universities’ financial responses, its findings have implications for university decision-makers and higher education policymakers across the globe when it comes to university management using calculative devices in persuading employees to work their way through financial hardship caused by an extreme health crisis-like COVID-19 pandemic.Originality/valueThis study adds more evidence that the use of budgets as a calculative tool continues to play a key role in organizations in the construction, mobilization and preservation of certain strategic and operational choices during volatilities. Especially, the same way of creating calculative-based solutions can be communicated via the colorful blending of different rhetoric to make it acceptable.

Sustainable Education at Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) and the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Bibliometric Review Study Field Review

“…Many HEIs had to shift their financial and operational strategies to address the financial impacts of the pandemic [67]. This included the adoption of cost-saving measures such as stopping hiring, furloughs, and reduced operating expenses, as well as the exploration of new revenue streams and partnerships to help offset the financial losses caused by the pandemic [68].…”

Universities in a contested space: The dominance of calculative accounting practices and the development of a research agenda

“…During the pandemic, many student organizations petitioned their universities for a reduction or refund of their tuition fees, as their perception of the Public Value generated by their university was obviously negative. University central management is more likely to see themselves as overcoming serious challenges and offering high Public Value (Hoque et al., 2022; Ng, 2021). However, the illustration, using the impact of the Covid‐19 pandemic, shows how the idea of a single number for Public Value estimates for universities (or any organization) may be difficult to achieve.…”

“…Value (Hoque et al, 2022;Ng, 2021). However, the illustration, using the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic, shows how the idea of a single number for Public Value estimates for universities (or any organization) may be difficult to achieve.…”

The Impact of Digital Transformation Readiness Towards the New Normalcy in the Education System

“…Commercial platforms including manufacturing, retail, transportation, wholesale, and education were halted for months but are now easing out slowly with more significant complexities as every country has its unique educational and economic security measures to deal with (Shafi et al, 2020). On the other hand, various universities and colleges face tremendous pressure in managing cash flows, especially private universities and colleges, derived from imbalances in delays, disruptions in the recovery funnel, and many other unexpected social and economic turbulence (Hoque et al, 2022). Despite the negative sentiments, various educational institutions are trying to explore the new standard silver lining.…”