Accounting Policies and Dividend Limitation: A European Comparison

Abstract

The adoption of IFRS by the EU has raised issues about its economic consequences in terms of, among others, volatility of corporate profits, taxation of profit and distribution of dividends. Indeed, it has brought the interactions between legal rules for dividend distribution and accounting policies back into focus. The EU company and accounting regulations are based on capital maintenance rules that involve limitations on dividend distribution when certain accounting policies are implemented in individual financial statements under local GAAP. However, while a majority of member states permit IFRS for individual financial statements, the EU regulations are silent on this issue. In this article, we outline an in-depth analysis on legal dividend distribution rules interactions with accounting policies in European countries, whether local GAAP or IFRS are applied. We have selected nine cases of potential recognition of unrealised gains in individual financial statements under local GAAP and/or IFRS, some of which are already specified in the EU regulations. For each case, we have analysed the national accounting regulations and the corporate laws. Our analysis reveals that the limitations on dividend distributions recommended by the EU have been most largely implemented in the national regulations, but not in all countries. It also sheds light on potential loopholes in the current European regulation regarding unrealised gains that may be more systematically recognised under IFRS than under local GAAP: unrealised gains arising from the recognition of deferred tax assets and unrealised gains arising from benefit pensions plan. To fill these gaps in the national regulations and to harmonise the legal basis for dividend distribution better within the EU, we suggest including in the European regulation the concept of ‘realised profits’ and thus ‘distributable profits’ as a required basis for dividend distribution. It involves in the first place identifying relevant criteria that may enable disentangling realised and unrealised profits or losses.