Accounting students' experience of an improved strategy of feedback on assessment

Abstract

Higher education institutions in South Africa are experiencing the effects of massification and diversification of the student body, necessitating students to take more responsibility for the management of their own learning. The education of chartered accountants in South Africa reflects this reality. Feedback on assignments and formative assessments is regarded as a key mechanism to facilitate students' development as independent learners. The practical logistics of providing one-onone feedback to an ever-increasing number of students necessitate a concerted change in feedback practice. The goal of this article is to report on the experience of undergraduate accounting students regarding the revised and more detailed system of feedback on assignments and formative assessments that was introduced by the authors. The researchers are of the opinion that the questionnaire cannot be tested at other universities, unless the total approach to feedback is instituted and supported. The research is underpinned by the theoretical framework of self-directed learning. Pragmatism and a mixed methods methodology is the relevant research paradigm underlying this inquiry and the concurrent triangulation approach is considered appropriate to this investigation. The study found that students were of the opinion that the new form of feedback on assessment enabled them to identify typical mistakes, recognise their individual strengths and weaknesses, gain from constructive criticism and conduct regular self-assessment. The quantitative inquiry clearly showed that students were overwhelmingly satisfied and impressed with the features of the revised strategy of feedback. However, the peer-assessment feature of the strategy was not received as positively, as students expressed anxiety in assessing their peers. The study has proven that a concerted change in focus could assist in student self-assessment and self-directedness. KeywordsFeedback on student assessment, accounting assessment, accounting education, formative assessment, peer assessment _______________________________ *Prof N Stegmann is an associate professor in the Department of Accountancy, University of Johannesburg, South Africa [nerines@uj.ac.za]. #Ms M Malan is a senior lecturer in the

The effects of personal epistemological beliefs on pedagogical use of information and communications technologies: A comparative case of Gauteng and North-West provinces in South Africa

“…An education specialist, Jansen (2014) argued that the government 'wrongly, but conveniently' uses the matric results as 'a barometer of the state of the school system', when all other data points otherwise to the reality that the education system has been deteriorating and failing. According to Stegmann and Malan (2016), Accounting, specifically in the Auditors and Chartered Accountant (CA) programmes, has been taught very successfully at the tertiary level at the University of Johannesburg in South Africa. After a pilot study involving 200 Accounting students to gauge the questionnaire's perceived face validity and an intensive review conducted by SAICA (2009) of the Accounting programmes at the university, a new teaching and learning strategy which entails self-directed learning was adopted by the university.…”

Open Learning in the African Context: Challenges and Possibilities for Self-directed Learning

“…In some cases, the researchers from the studies in the corpus made use of questionnaires developed by themselves (De Bruin & Cornelius, 2011;Petersen, 2018;Stegmann & Malan, 2016).…”

“…• observations (Abubakar & Arshad, 2015;Lumina, 2005;Malan et al, 2014); • open-ended questionnaires (Aheto et al, 2017;Breed, 2016;Du Toit et al, 2016;Jacobs & Van Loggerenberg, 1996;Maistry, 2009;Mthethwa, 2018;Olivier, 2016;Petersen, 2018;Stegmann & Malan, 2016); The same group of research participants were used for both studies noted here • researcher reflections (Lumina, 2005);…”

“…While with an overview of different studies on portfolios, De Beer (2019b), Kruger et al (2015) and Terblanché (2010) found that portfolios can be used effectively to support SDL. Stegmann and Malan (2016) explored the role of detailed feedback and peer assessment, and they found despite some negativity towards peer assessment among students, changes in the way feedback were approached supported self-assessment and SDL.…”

A Framework for Computerized Progress Feedback in Tertiary Education

“…Feedback in learning comprises information that a lecturer or teacher provides a learner with, relating to accomplishment or content understanding (Hattie and Timperley, 2007). Although academic performance feedback and its effect on learning have been extensively researched in recent years (Belcadhi, 2016;Semley et al, 2016;Stegemann and Malan, 2016), students' learning methods have started to change. Specifically, computer and internet use in learning are increasingly being adopted (Uğur and Turan, 2018).…”