Accuracy of cervical pedicle screw placement with four different designs of rapid prototyping navigation templates: a human cadaveric study

Abstract

Purpose: Due to the high perforation rate of cervical pedicle screw placement, we have designed four different types of rapid prototyping navigation templates to enhance the accuracy of cervical pedicle screw placement. Methods: Fifteen human cadaveric cervical spines from C2 to C7 were randomly divided into five groups, with three specimens in each group. The diameter of pedicle screw used in this study was 3.5 mm. Groups 1-4 were assisted by the two-level template, one-level bilateral template, one-level unilateral template and one-level point-contact template, respectively. Group 5 was without any navigation template. After the surgery, the accuracy of screw placement in the five groups was evaluated using postoperative computed tomographic scans to observe whether the screw breached the pedicle cortex. Results: A total of 180 pedicle screws were inserted without any accidents. The accuracy rate was 75%, 100%, 100%, 91.7%, and 63.9%, respectively, from Groups 1 to 5. All the template groups were significantly higher than Group 5, though the two-level navigation template group was significantly lower than the other three template groups. The operation time was 4.72 ± 0.28, 4.81 ± 0.29, 5.03 ± 0.35, 8.42 ± 0.36, and 10.05 ± 0.52 min, respectively, from Groups 1 to 5. The no template and point-contact procedures were significantly more time-consuming than the template procedures. Conclusion:This study demonstrated that four different design types of navigation templates achieved a higher accuracy in assisting cervical pedicle screw placement than no template insertion. However, the two-level template's accuracy was the lowest compared to the other three templates. Meanwhile, these templates avoided fluoroscopy during the surgery and decreased the operation time. It is always very challenging to translate cadaveric studies to clinical practice. Hence, the one-level bilateral, unilateral, and point-contact navigation templates designed by us need to be meticulously tested to verify their accuracy and safety.

Accuracy of Lumbosacral Pedicle Screw Placement in Dogs: A Novel 3D Printed Patient-Specific Drill Guide versus Freehand Technique in Novice and Expert Surgeons

“…In the medical literature, accuracy has been determined using specialized software that measures surface deviation, 32 but a grading system is also still used as a sole assessment of accuracy. 33 34 After taking the above in consideration, we adopted the grading system used by Chen and colleagues, which determines the ratio of the screw diameter to the implant corridor width. The overall accuracy in our study was lower compared with previous studies, which can be explained by the variety of study designs and a stricter grading system used in this study.…”

A Novel Radiographic Analysis System for Subaxial Cervical Spine Pedicle Screw Placement

“…Alternatively, a guidance system such as O-arm-based three-dimensional (3D) navigation, 3D model, navigation templates, Doppler donography, robotic guidance system, [7][8][9][10][11][12] or augmented reality-based navigation [13 14] is needed to prevent placement failure. The use of these resources is limited because of their high cost and steep associated learning curve however, and they cannot be widely applied in all kinds of hospitals.…”