Accuracy of Stroke Identification by Paramedics in a Metropolitan Prehospital Setting: A Cohort Study

Abstract

<jats:p>ObjectivesAcute stroke is a medical emergency. Identifying patients suffering a stroke is crucial if paramedics are to maximize delivery of appropriate management. One suggested stroke recognition tool is ‘FAST’ (Face, Arms, Speech, Time) but the accuracy of identifying stroke is unknown. We aimed to (1) examine how paramedics identify patients with stroke; (2) compare paramedic identification of stroke with the Emergency Department (ED) discharge diagnosis of stroke.Methods A retrospective cohort study was conducted in the Perth metropolitan area in Western Australia between July 2012 and June 2014 using linked data from ambulance and ED databases. Patients aged 45+ years, transported to ED by road ambulance and assigned the ambulance problem code or ED discharge diagnosis of stroke were selected. Positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV), specificity and sensitivity were calculated. Text fields were examined for documentation that patients met FAST criteria.Results There were 2,217 patients were identified as stroke by paramedics. Of 1834 patients diagnosed as stroke in ED, 876 patients were not identified as stroke by paramedics. Sensitivity for identification of stroke was 958/1834 (52.2%). Of 2,096 patients who were identified as stroke by paramedics and had an ED record, 958 patients were identified as stroke by paramedics and in ED. PPV was 958/2096 (45.7%), NPV 99.5% and specificity 99.4%. Paramedics recorded 2 or 3 stroke signs and symptoms in 1,137 (51%) patients.Conclusion A systematic approach is needed to better identify patients with stroke in the prehospital setting.</jats:p>

Linking Data From the Australian Stroke Clinical Registry With Ambulance and Emergency Administrative Data in Victoria

“…We provide evidence for the successful linkage of ambulance records with a stroke registry for investigation of prehospital care in an Australian setting. We used AuSCR confirmed stroke diagnosis as a reference for patients with stroke unlike some studies 16 that use provisional ED discharge diagnosis. Secondly, Ambulance Victoria is the only provider of emergency ambulance services in Victoria.…”

Stroke recognition efficiency by emergency medical dispatchers

“…According to a recent study, the FAST test has 70% sensitivity in identifying acute stroke. 8,9 The minimal sample size required for this investigation was 220 cases, based on a recurrence of 52 percent of stroke suspected patients, accuracy of 95 percent and a 5% error in sensitivity estimation.…”

Prehospital Assessment of Non-Traumatic Abdominal Pain

“…A third version is also practiced in countries, such as Sweden with ambulances staffed with very skillful nurses (7). Although there is a higher accuracy of prehospital diagnosis by emergency physicians, compared to that of nurses or paramedics, studies have shown that the management of emergency patients by paramedics is both safe and possible (8)(9)(10)(11)(12)(13)(14). One way to increase the safety and accuracy of the paramedics' assessment is the use of guidelines and protocols (3)(4)(5)(6).…”