Conspectus
The structures of molecules
can be different in different phases.
Intermolecular forces, even those of weak noncovalent interactions
(WNCIs), can lead to a preference for quite different conformations
in the solid, the gas, and the liquid phases. WNCIs can cause variations
in bond lengths, angles, and torsional angles. Since structure is
a fundamental concept in chemistry, the knowledge of structural changes
with phase is important to understand the source and effects of distorting
contributions from WNCIs but also as a predictive tool for the design
and stabilization of new bonding situations.
X-ray crystallography
is ubiquitous and now mostly straightforward
to perform, but facilities for the determination of accurate gas-phase
structure determination are rare, and gas-phase work is laborious
and time-consuming. There are currently about 1.25 million crystal
structures and more than 12 500 experimental gas-phase structures,
but the intersection of the two data sets that can tell us about the
structural differences of the same molecule in different phases is
surprisingly small.
In this Account, we describe several cases
of WNCI-dominated systems
for which accurate experimental structure determinations exist for
both the gas phase and the solid state and, in one case, also for
solution. The examples include aryl–aryl, aryl–alkyl,
and alkyl–alkyl interactions; systems with chalcogen and halogen
bonding; and fluorine-based interactions in arylboranes. We work out
the role of WNCIs in stabilizing large, strained, or sterically overloaded
molecules. We will show how flexible molecules will fold under the
action of WNCIs when isolated in the gas and how they fold or unfold
when they are embedded in an environment of neighbors in crystals.
We will show how they can vary in strength when the substitution patterns
in aryl groups are changed by different halogens and how intramolecular
WNCIs, such as those forming rings, change when such systems experience
additional intermolecular WNCIs.
Overall, we hope that this
Account will give the reader an idea
of the type and magnitude of structural changes that can be expected
from a free molecule in the gas phase or a single molecule calculated
by quantum chemistry compared with one embedded in a crystal. This
should define the limits of comparability and provide some predictive
concepts of the distortions and variations to be expected.