We investigated the in vitro metabolism and estrogenic and antiestrogenic activity of toremifene (TOR), tamoxifen (TAM) and their metabolites to better understand the potential effects of cytochrome P-450 2D6 (CYP2D6) status on the activity of these drugs in women with breast cancer. The plasma concentrations of TOR and its N-desmethyl (NDM) and 4-hydroxy (4-OH) metabolites during steady-state dosing with TOR were also determined. Unlike TOR, TAM and its NDM metabolite were extensively oxidized to 4-OH TAM and 4-OH-NDM TAM by CYP2D6, and the rate of metabolism was affected by CYP2D6 status. 4-OH-NDM TOR concentrations were not measurable at steady state in plasma of subjects taking 80 mg of TOR. Molecular modeling provided insight into the lack of 4-hydroxylation of TOR by CYP2D6. The 4-OH and 4-OH-NDM metabolites of TOR and TAM bound to estrogen receptor (ER) subtypes with fourfold to 30-fold greater affinity were 35-to 187-fold more efficient at antagonizing ER transactivation and had antiestrogenic potency that was up to 360-fold greater than their parent drugs. Our findings suggest that variations in CYP2D6 metabolic capacity may cause significant differences in plasma concentrations of active TAM metabolites (i.e., 4-OH TAM and 4-OH-NDM TAM) and contribute to variable pharmacologic activity. Unlike TAM, the clinical benefits in subjects taking TOR to treat metastatic breast cancer would not likely be subject to allelic variation in CYP2D6 status or affected by coadministration of CYP2D6-inhibiting medications.Tamoxifen (TAM) is the most widely used hormone therapy for breast cancer. Toremifene (TOR), a chlorinated derivative of TAM, is also an approved treatment for metastatic breast cancer in postmenopausal women.1,2 Although TAM is the prototypical drug in the selective estrogen receptor modulator (SERM) class, its clinical efficacy and safety are known to vary widely among individuals.3 TOR is equally effective in breast cancer treatment.4-7 However, TOR may have reduced genotoxicity and lower potential to induce secondary endometrial cancers 8,9 and may therefore be considered as an alternative to TAM as firstline therapy for patients with ER-positive advanced breast cancer.TAM is extensively metabolized. The clinical benefit of TAM is thought to arise from its conversion to active metabolites, chiefly 4-hydroxy TAM (4-OH TAM) and 4-OH-N-desmethyl TAM (4-OH-NDM TAM, otherwise known as endoxifen; Fig. 1). [10][11][12] These metabolites bind to the ER with up to 30-fold greater affinity than TAM, and this increased potency for binding translates into enhanced antiestrogen activity.
13-16Whether these metabolites are responsible for TAM's variable clinical efficacy is a topic of considerable controversy. TAM is known to be metabolized extensively by the cytochrome P450 (CYP) enzyme system, primarily by the CYP3A4 and 2D6 isoforms. 17 CYP3A4 generates the major circulating metabolite mono-NDM TAM
18; however, the formation of the active TAM metabolites apparently requires cytochrome P-450 2D6 (CYP2D6).19 CY...