Actual rate of the management fee in mutual funds of different styles

Abstract

Research background: Exponential growth of passive mutual funds after 2007?2008 global financial crisis put pressure on active fund managers to lower the management fees. The real costs of active fund management are, however, very often higher than the values of management fees reported publicly. Thus it is not easy to decide on the quality of the fund management and estimate the level of management charges optimal for the future fund performance. Purpose of the article: In this study, we propose to utilize an actual rate of the management fee (ARMF) disclosed in the management company financial statements as a measure of the real value of the management costs and investigate its determinants in mutual funds of different styles. Methods: Using a dataset of 21,618 monthly observations for 500 mutual funds from a market of diversified structure and high management fees charged we test the operating model of a mutual fund performance, and derive the formula of a before-fee return with the ARMF as its component. The fund performance is measured by a raw before-fee return and two types of risk-adjusted alphas based on the multifactor model of Carhart (1997) and the fund attributes. Later, using panel data we explain ARMF by mutual fund performance and attributes. We also compare the results to the ones obtained for the total operational cost (TOC) ? a value similar to ARMF that is disclosed in mutual fund financial reports. Findings & value added: We find that the proposed ARMF is related more to the size and not to the performance, age or a cash flow of mutual funds. We observe it among all studied fund styles. The largest deviations of the average ARMF are seen in the management companies that belong to the banks? capital groups. The proposed measure of the management fee included in the operating model of a mutual fund performance can be used for any local mutual fund worldwide, and compared with other fund markets of more or less diversified style structures.

Analyzing the Performance of Pakistan Equity Mutual Funds Using Multifactor Models: Pre-COVID Analysis

“…2 into the influence of other factors on the relationship between market risk and mutual fund performance. Perez and Szymczyk (2022) revealed that the impact of market risk on mutual fund performance is moderated by factors such as fund size and investment style. Given the debates, this research proposes a significant association between mutual fund performance and the market risk factor.…”

Active Management in Polish Domestic Treasury Bond Funds

“…However, it is worth to repeat such study in emerging markets like the Polish one, since it is very dynamically growing in the European Union, but also because it has a different history, background, and the structure of the investment funds than in the most developed fund market in the world, namely in the USA. In Poland, the research has been carried out occasionally so far (Miziołek, 2015;Bogdanowicz et al, 2017;Trzebiński, 2022), and has been limited mainly to equity funds (except Perez and Szymczyk [2022] who studied different types of funds).…”