Gas plasmas, often referred to as cold physical plasma, are currently being investigated for their potential to serve as anti-cancer agents. Along similar lines, gas plasma-oxidized liquids as a carrier for reactive oxygen species have found their way into pre-clinical research. This review focuses on in vivo studies that utilized such gas plasma-oxidized liquids for cancer therapies. These pre-clinical tumor models, treatment modalities, and types of liquids that were used are summarized and critically discussed. Among these studies, significant results were observed, indicating the potential of oxidative liquids to serve as an anticancer treatment. However, several steps have to be taken to enhance the quality and translational capacities of this approach in order to gain clinical acceptance for possible future cancer therapies. The most crucial steps include not only a careful selection of suitable liquids, with respect to their approval as medical products, but also the consideration of orthotopic and immunocompetent animal tumor models. This would increase the relevance of such studies and simultaneously allow studying the contribution of the most potent of all anti-cancer effectors, the immune system.