Acute traumatic brain injury presentations and the use of head CT scans in the Emergency Department

Abstract

Objective: The use of CT head scanning for traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a vital diagnostic tool, guided by risk stratification tools. This study aims to review the use of CT head scans for TBI in two Australasian Emergency Departments (ED) in New Zealand.Methods: Retrospective observational design of patients referred for head CT from ED to exclude a significant intracranial injury between 1st September 2018 and 31st August 2019. Clinical data were collected regarding presenting patterns, identification of injuries on CT scan and adherence to CT guidelines.Results: Out of 425 cases reviewed, a clinically significant injury was identified in 41 (10%) patients. Patients who reported loss (32% vs 20% p < 0.05) or possible loss of consciousness (34% vs 22% p < 0.05) and had GCS < 13 (17% vs 8%, p < 0.05) or focal neurology (10% vs 3%, p < 0.05) were more likely to have a significantly intracranial injury on CT. Interestingly, 17 (41%) patients with significant injury were GCS 15 with no focal neurology. NICE guidelines were adhered to in 364 (86%) patients. In the 14% of cases that did not meet guideline criteria, all CT head scans were negative.Conclusion: CT head scans are a valuable tool in TBI and guidelines successfully identify those with significant intracranial injuries. However, the rate of significant injury for the total population requiring head CT remains low, with over 90% of head CTs in the population normal, despite high guideline compliance perhaps identifying a role for novel objective tests in ED guidelines internationally.