Adapting Online Patient Decision Aids: Effects of Modality and Narration Style on Patients’ Satisfaction, Information Recall and Informed Decision Making

Abstract

Audiovisual and narrative information are often used in online decision aids. However, few studies have tested whether these strategies are more effective compared to other types of information. We tested the effect of these strategies on satisfaction with the information, recall and informed decision-making in a 2 (Modality: audiovisual vs. textual) x 2 (Narration style: narrative vs. factual) experimental design. Data was collected in an online experiment among 262 analogue cancer patients. Since most cancer patients are older people, we also assessed if the effectiveness of these strategies differs depending on the patient's age. Data was analyzed using Structural Equation Modeling. Findings showed audiovisual modality had a positive effect on satisfaction. Moreover, audiovisual modality improved recall, both directly and indirectly via satisfaction, which subsequently resulted in better-informed decision-making. Narratives resulted in more satisfaction, but not better recall or informed decision-making. These effects were found in patients of all ages.

Enhancing Specific Health Literacy with a Digital Evidence-Based Patient Decision Aid for Hypertension: A Randomized Controlled Trial

“… 34 , 35 For this purpose, the evidence-based information is presented in plain language, descriptive graphics, and video-statements that display the expertise and experience of real patients, physicians, and other healthcare workers. 31 Although each EbPDA refers to a specific medical decision situation, the presented content can serve as a generic example for other medical decisions and therefore contributes to general health literacy. This may be especially important for the didactical goal to engage participants in posing the three questions, an approach that was successfully taken also in a recent Australian study within the AskShareKnow-Network that aimed at health literacy and SDM.…”

“…34,35 For this purpose, the evidence-based information is presented in plain language, descriptive graphics, and video-statements that display the expertise and experience of real patients, physicians, and other healthcare workers. 31 Although each EbPDA refers to a specific medical decision situation, the…”

“…29,30 The provided medical content is based on a systematic review of current evidence for antihypertensive therapies.- 25 It is presented with written, graphical, and video-based information, featuring interactive elements to illustrate the relation of personal preferences, possible choices, and experiences of affected patients, physicians, and related healthcare workers. 31 The complete EbPDA is peerreviewed by medical and scientific experts and underwent user-testing by laypeople.…”

A Voice-Annotated Digital Decision Aid to Promote Child Influenza Vaccination: A Feasibility Study

“…Younger and more tech-savvy people (such as parents of young children) prefer digital-based decision aids to paper-based ones as they allow access to more in-depth information beyond the doctor’s consultation room [ 22 , 23 ]. Combining higher interactivity, audiovisual modality and a narrative style, these platforms improve user satisfaction and knowledge recall leading to better-informed decision-making [ 23 , 24 ].…”

Annual Report on the Evaluation of Patient Satisfaction at a Pneumophthisiology Hospital

“…Patient satisfaction influences his clinical outcomes and last but not least, his relationship with the service provider. (6,7,8) A satisfied patient will confidently return to the doctor or hospital, increasing addressability. Patient satisfaction assessment is a tool for measuring how the medical unit meets patients' values and expectations.…”