Addressing medical absenteeism in pre-vocational secondary students: effectiveness of a public health intervention, using a quasi-experimental design

Abstract

BackgroundStudents’ health and school absenteeism affect educational level, with adverse effects on their future health. This interdependence is reflected in medical absenteeism. In the Netherlands, a public health intervention has been developed to address medical absenteeism in pre-vocational secondary education. This study aims to investigate the effectiveness of this intervention on students’ medical absenteeism, compared to “medical absenteeism policy as usual”.MethodsA quasi-experimental design with an intervention group (493 students) and a control group (445 students) was applied. Multilevel analysis was used to study differences in the development of the level of a student’s medical absence over time (after 3 and 12 months).ResultsIn the intervention group, the level of absenteeism decreased from 8.5 days reported sick in 12 school weeks to 5.7 days after 3 months, and to 4.9 days after 12 months. The number of absence periods fell from 3.9 in 12 school weeks to 2.5 after 3 months, and to 2.2 after 12 months. In the control group, the absence days initially decreased from 9.9 days reported sick in 12 school weeks to 8.4 days after 3 months, after which an increase to 8.9 days was measured. The number of absence periods initially decreased from 4.5 in 12 school weeks to 3.5, after which an increase to 3.7 was measured. The number of absence days per period remained about the same in both groups.ConclusionsThe study provides first indications for the intervention to be effective for Dutch pre-vocational secondary students with increased medical absence rates. The intervention, which consists of personalised management of medical absenteeism by systematic identification of students with extensive medical absenteeism and consistent referral to youth health care physicians, appears to reduce the absence rates more effectively than “medical absenteeism policy as usual”. The effectiveness of the intervention is shown primarily by a decrease in the number of periods reported sick.

Addressing sickness absence among adolescents and young adults: an evaluation of the Medical Advice for Sick-reported Students intervention

“…justify conclusions), the results will be interpreted alongside the literature. Our finding that a decrease in sickness absence was found in those in the intervention condition at six-month follow-up, compared with those in the control condition is in line with a previous study evaluating the MASS intervention at pre-vocational education [ 18 ]. A meta-analysis by Tanner-Smith et al also found that vocationally oriented programs showed promise in reducing school absenteeism [ 42 ].…”

“…This system offers nationwide preventive health care through anticipatory guidance for children and youth to promote growth, development, health, and well-being. The MASS intervention was initially implemented in pre-vocational education among students aged 12 to 16 years [ 18 ]. A significantly larger reduction in sickness absence was observed among students in the intervention condition receiving the MASS intervention than in the control condition.…”

De M@ZL-app: een eHealthapplicatie ter ondersteuning van de aanpak bij ziekteverzuim

“…Jongeren met ziekteverzuim worden vroegtijdig gesignaleerd en begeleid. M@ZL is effectief gebleken in het verminderen van ziekteverzuim en wil jongeren de regie laten nemen, maar biedt hiervoor in de praktijk nog onvoldoende houvast [ 2 , 4 ].…”

Professionals’ and Students’ Perceived Needs for an Online Supportive Application for Reducing School Absence and Stimulating Reintegration: Concept Mapping Study

“…The MASS intervention has dual purposes: (1) stimulating collaboration between professionals involved in the care of a medically absent student, in particular schools, youth health care, and the school attendance service, and (2) optimizing students' health, maximizing students' participation in school activities, and limiting school absenteeism for medical reasons [17,18,24,25]. The MASS intervention shows promising effects regarding the reduction of absenteeism in secondary schools for medical reasons [25][26][27]. However, certain aspects of the intervention could still be further improved, for example, regarding the monitoring of students and stimulating students' autonomy regarding their situation, as well as regarding the collaboration between professionals [28].…”