We discuss a unique case of a benign breast neoplasm that initially appeared to be an intracystic papillary carcinoma on digital breast tomosynthesis, ultrasound, and contrast-enhanced mammogram. However, subsequent histopathological examination (HPE) revealed it to be a benign adenomyoepithelioma, an uncommon neoplasm in the breast. Understanding this rare condition and confirming it pre-operatively through HPE can prevent unnecessary aggressive treatment.