Amongst the side effects of triptans, a substantial percentage of patients experience injection site pain and tenderness, the underlying mechanism of which is unknown. We found the dose range from 10 fg – 1000 ng (intradermal) sumatriptan induced a complex dose-dependent mechanical hyperalgesia in the male rat, with distinct peaks, at 1 pg and 10 ng, with no hyperalgesia at 1 ng. In female rats, there was 1 broad peak. The highest dose (1000 ng) did not produce hyperalgesia in either sex. We evaluated the receptors mediating sumatriptan hyperalgesia (1 pg, 1 and 10 ng). In male rats, while the injection of an antagonist for the serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine, 5-HT) receptor subtype 1B (5-HT1B), but not 5-HT1D, markedly inhibited sumatriptan (1 pg hyperalgesia, at 10 ng a 5-HT1D receptor antagonist completely eliminated hyperalgesia. In contrast, in female rats, the 5-HT1D, but not 5-HT1B, receptor antagonist completely blocked sumatriptan (1 pg and 10 ng) hyperalgesia. Both 5-HT1B and 5-HT1D receptor antagonists attenuated hyperalgesia (1 ng) in females. Sumatriptan (1 ng)-induced hyperalgesia in female rats is G-protein-coupled estrogen receptor 30 dependent. While selective 5-HT1B, but not 5-HT1D, receptor agonists produces a robust hyperalgesia, when co-injected the hyperalgesia induced by 5-HT1B receptor agonist was attenuated. The mechanical hyperalgesia induced by sumatriptan (1 pg and 10 ng) is dependent on the Gi-protein α subunit and protein kinase A (PKA). Understanding the mechanisms responsible for the complex dose dependence for triptan hyperalgesia may provide useful information for the design of anti-migraine drugs with improved therapeutic profiles.