Adherence to guidelines and suboptimal practice in term breech delivery with perinatal death- a population-based case-control study in Norway

Abstract

Background In a recent population-based study we reported excess risk of neonatal mortality associated with vaginal breech delivery. In this case-control study we examine whether deviations from Norwegian guidelines are more common in breech deliveries resulting in intrapartum or neonatal deaths than in breech deliveries where the offspring survives, and if these deaths are potentially avoidable. Material and methods Case-control study completed as a perinatal audit including term breech deliveries of singleton without congenital anomalies in Norway from 1999 to 2015. Deliveries where the child died intrapartum or in the neonatal period were case deliveries. For each case, two control deliveries who survived were identified. All the included deliveries were reviewed by four obstetricians independently assessing if the deaths in the case group might have been avoided and if the management of the deviations from Norwegian guidelines were more common in case than in control deliveries. Results Thirty-one case and 62 control deliveries were identified by the Medical Birth Registry of Norway. After exclusion of non-eligible deliveries, 22 case and 31 control deliveries were studied. Three case and two control deliveries were unplanned home deliveries, while all in-hospital deliveries were in line with national guidelines. Antenatal care and/or management of in-hospital deliveries was assessed as suboptimal in seven (37%) case and two (7%) control deliveries (p = 0.020). Three case deliveries were completed as planned caesarean delivery and 12 (75%) of the remaining 16 deaths were considered potentially avoidable had planned caesarean delivery been done. In seven of these 16 deliveries, death was associated with cord prolapse or difficult delivery of the head. Conclusion All in-hospital breech deliveries were in line with Norwegian guidelines. Seven of twelve potentially avoidable deaths were associated with birth complications related to breech presentation. However, suboptimal care was more common in case than control deliveries. Further improvement of intrapartum care may be obtained through continuous rigorous training and feedback from repeated perinatal audits.

Facility-based stillbirth review processes used in different countries across the world: a systematic review

“…For 29 out of 68 studies (43%), Government agencies (15 studies 3 , 14 , 17 , 18 , 24 , 25 , 30 , 32 , 34 , 35 , 36 , 38 , 39 , 72 , 75 ) or other funding bodies such as non-governmental organisations (9 studies 19 , 20 , 22 , 23 , 51 , 62 , 67 , 69 , 73 ), universities or professional associations (2 studies 26 , 47 ), and research grants (3 studies 10 , 11 , 77 ) were solely responsible for commissioning the review process. Fifteen studies 12 , 15 , 27 , 33 , 43 , 46 , 48 , 50 , 58 , 60 , 63 , 66 , 70 , 71 out of 68 received funding from two or more organisations (22%), but 24 out of the 68 studies (35%) received no funding or did not list any funding information for the stillbirth review process.…”

Practical insight into upright breech birth from birth videos: A structured analysis

“…However, observation from personal experience is often based on small samples and prone to recall and confirmation bias . Reviews of neonatal mortalities associated with term vaginal breech births often identify suboptimal care, and delay is often implicated . Identification of common characteristics of births with good outcomes may provide additional insight.…”

Induction of labor in breech presentations ‐ a retrospective cohort study

“…25 Suboptimal antenatal care and/or management of in-hospital deliveries is more common in deliveries with intrapartum or neonatal death than in deliveries where the offspring survives. 26 Multiple methods have been tried in the search for improved birth outcomes for breechpresenting fetuses. A retrospective cohort study published in 2017 compared vaginal delivery in the dorsal position with vaginal delivery in an upright position.…”

“…Suboptimal antenatal care and/or management of inhospital deliveries is more common in deliveries with intrapartum or neonatal death than in deliveries where the offspring survives 26. …”