The intricate interplay of crude oil composition and additives critically affects hydrate formation and flow behavior, which is significant for flow assurance particularly in deepwater. To investigate, we varied the hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties by proportioning two nonionic surfactants (Span 80 and Tween 80) and conducting hydrate formation experiments in a visual rocking cell. The results show that the increasing hydrophilic−lipophilic balance (HLB) value shifted emulsions from water-in-oil to multiple and oil-in-water phases and significantly affected the hydrate formation among different emulsion types, with a marked increase in the hydrate formation rate in the HLB range of 9 to 11. Slurries maintained flowability due to low hydrate conversion, yet higher HLB (>11) led to slight agglomeration and deposition. In addition, the impacts of water conversion were investigated by multiple pressurization, showing that the hydrate formation amount affected slurry flowability but was primarily dependent on the hydrophilicity and hydrophobicity of the surfactants. When the HLB was below 11, the final water conversion was about 80%, but the formed hydrate still exhibited good dispersion and flowability. In contrast, HLB exceeding 13 resulted in extensive adhesion and deposition on the cell walls. When the water conversion reached about 40%, flowability was completely lost and hydrate blockage occurred.