Advancing Regional Strategic Environmental Assessment in Canada's Western Arctic: Implementation Opportunities and Challenges

Abstract

The absence of Regional Strategic Environmental Assessment (R-SEA) in Canada's western Arctic has raised many questions concerning the country's preparedness for offshore Arctic energy development, given the constraints of project assessments in addressing long-term cumulative impacts of energy development on the marine environment and local communities. There has been much interest in R-SEA in recent years, and a growing body of research on the benefits of strategic approaches to environmental assessment, but relatively little attention has been given to implementation. This paper examines key opportunities for and challenges to the implementation of R-SEA in Canada's western Arctic. Results reinforce concerns that the current approach to environmental assessment in Canada's western Arctic is insufficient to address expanding offshore energy development. However, results also indicate several challenges to be addressed to advance R-SEA in the offshore environment including governance, stakeholder resistance to a futures-based approach, the timing of implementation, managing the diversity of expectations about R-SEA, and the nature and scope of alternatives assessment.

The changing Arctic Ocean: consequences for biological communities, biogeochemical processes and ecosystem functioning

“…Significant changes in the type, extent and thickness of ice cover [6], meltwater input [7] and water mass dynamics [8], coupled with warming and ocean acidification [9], have already begun to impact ecosystem processes and the flora and fauna that inhabit a range of Arctic habitats [10]. The pace of change is such that our understanding of the way in which Arctic systems are structured and function is outdated, and insufficient to inform management, mitigation and adaptation efforts across the region [11,12]. Projections indicate that, even if global stabilization of temperature below 1.5°C is realized, changes will continue to manifest over an extended period, perhaps even millennial timescales [13] 2020 The Author(s) Published by the Royal Society.…”

SEA Planning Responses to Estuarine Cumulative Effects of Watershed Urbanisation

“…This type of integration occurred under the NZ Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA) (NZ Government 1991). Statutory requirements in the European Union (EU) (Bragagnolo et al 2012) and Canada (Fidler and Noble 2013) have led to the incorporation of requirements for CEA into SEA and/or Sustainability Appraisals (SA) (Morrison-Saunders and Fischer 2006).…”

Cumulative Effects Research: Achievements, Status, Directions and Challenges in the Canadian Context

“…First, scholars are focusing on the development of frameworks and methodologies to advance CE practice from the project to the regional scale (Gunn and Noble, 2009;Fidler and Noble, 2013). The concept of regional CE is not new, promoted by the Alberta Society of Professional Biologists in the mid-1990s (Kennedy, 1995).…”