The control of selectivity in the
cross-coupling of two similar
compounds is a classic challenge in heterogeneous catalysis. Here,
it is shown that the phase in which the catalysis is performed has
a dramatic impact on the selectivity of the oxidative coupling of
alcohols to esters over unsupported nanoporous gold catalysts, affording
nearly optimal cross-coupling to a single ester at equimolar concentrations
in the liquid. Operation in the liquid vs the gas phase affects (1)
the relative C–H activation rates of methoxy and 1-propoxy,
(2) the fraction of C–H activation which leads to esters vs
aldehydes, and (3) the fraction of esters which results from cross-coupling
vs self-coupling. While activation of the critical, adsorbed alkoxy
intermediate 1-propoxy is faster than methoxy in both phases of operation,
the liquid phase is more effective in coupling the resulting aldehyde
with adsorbed methoxy or 1-propoxy to yield an ester. Additionally,
operation in the liquid phase promotes cross-coupling to methyl propionate,
whereas in the gas-phase, self-coupling of 1-propanol to propyl propionate
is favored. The promotion of self-coupling in the gas phase results
from the stabilization of larger alkoxides on the surface by Au-alkyl
van der Waals forces. However, such forces do not appear to be dominant
in the liquid phase, as evidenced by similar cross-coupling selectivities
of methanol with ethanol, 1-propanol, and 1-butanol. The introduction
of steric hindrance into the higher alcohol (i.e., 2-methyl-1-propanol)
further promotes cross-coupling. This promotion is attributed to a
kinetic preference for an aldehyde to couple with less-hindered alkoxides.
Altogether, these findings demonstrate that alcohol cross-coupling
selectivities are strongly impacted by the phase in which the catalysis
is conducted, thus altering the phase provides opportunities for selective
and efficient chemical syntheses.