Aesthetic objects on display: The objectification of fashion models as a situated practice

Abstract

This article unravels the process of objectification by empirically examining a social context where it occurs almost incessantly: fashion modeling. Drawing on an ethnography of fashion modeling in Amsterdam, Paris and Warsaw, I argue that objectification is neither ubiquitous nor one-dimensional: it takes place in specific social contexts and unfolds itself differently under different social conditions. Moreover, objectification is not unidirectional: it is done by and happens to both men and women. By taking an experiential perspective which involves models' subjective responses to being objectified, I call into question theoretical arguments of objectification pertaining to disempowered subjects, and the assumption that objectification is inherently negative or immoral. Instead, I argue that objectification is socially rooted in institutions and specific situations and that this matters considerably for its varying forms, levels of intensity and the emotional and practical responses it evokes in people. This does not imply that objectification is less compelling as a process, or easy to avoid. Objectification might be all the more effective exactly because the process is embedded in different social contexts, and adapts itself accordingly.

Structure, Strategy and Self in Cultural Peripheries: Theorizing the Periphery in the Polish and Dutch Fashion Fields

“…The peripheral character of Dutch fashion was a salient theme: informants were oriented towards international standards and complained about the lack of glamour, status and quality of the dependent Dutch field. Study 2 investigated fashion modelling in France, the Netherlands and Poland [Holla 2016; 2018; 2020]. While the Paris field proved quite distinct, the Dutch and Polish findings showed striking similarities in field structure, working conditions, aesthetic standards, and fashion professionals’ self-experience.…”

Pretty in Plastic: Aesthetic authenticity in Barbie Land

“…The central ideas of aesthetic labouring connect to the related concepts of biological capital (Pickard, 2018), glamour labour (Wissinger, 2016), and beauty work (Clarke, 2010). Debates across these related conceptual areas, prompted increased focus on the wider context for aesthetic concerns beyond specific organisations and attention turned to aesthetics within contemporary neoliberal economies (Holla, 2018). This lead Elias et al (2017: 5) to observe that 'neoliberalism makes us all aesthetic entrepreneurs'.…”