African business leadership: Perspectives from aspiring young leaders

Abstract

Orientation: Although a lot is written about leadership in Africa, little empirical research has been conducted and published in prominent academic journals, which comprehensively and specifically define the concept of African business leadership.Research purpose: The goal of the research study was to define the African business leadership comprehensively, tapping into the views of young leaders and making a contribution to the discourse and literature on leadership in Africa.Motivation for the study: Whilst business leadership practices are deemed to be universal by some, others argue that the matter is geographically specific. The latter view is supported by those interested in decolonisation and Africanisation. Although politically inspired and philosophically embedded definitions of African leadership are readily available, definitions stemming from empirical processes seem to be absent.Research approach, design and method: This research focuses on the sub-Saharan region, which accounts for the greater part of the African continent. A total of 121 adult students, representing 14 sub-Saharan countries, participated in this study. The participants were part of the Young African Leaders Initiative, a leadership development programme facilitated by the University of South Africa. A cross sectional survey design was used, as part of which open-ended questions were posed to the young leaders. Summative content analysis (Cohort 1) was uses to identify elements central to African leadership, and directed content analysis was then framed based on inter-relational plots, which include all these identified themes.Method: A cross-sectional survey design was used, as part of which open-ended questions were posed to the young leaders. Summative content analysis (Cohort 1) was used to identify elements central to African business leadership, and directed content analysis (Cohort 2) was applied to verify the themes. A definition of African business leadership was then framed based on inter-relational plots, which include all these identified themes.Main findings: Eight elements typical of African business leadership were identified and, following an analysis of inter-relational plots, a definition incorporating the participants’ inputs was crafted. African business leadership is seen as unique to leaders on the continent (Afrocentric), as an act of service to the community (Ubuntu), operating in challenging and resource-deprived environments (because of the legacy of colonialism) and providing hope for creating a better future. African business leadership is further seen as being dominated by those in positions of (political) authority, who engage in entrepreneurial activities, and yet as still requiring development because many leaders are corrupt (brokenness), which seems to be legitimised by post-colonial sentiments (Afro-centric).Contribution: The research study presents a multidimensional perspective on defining African business leadership, reiterating the admirable community orientation, but also the skill gaps, and therefore, the need for improvement.Practical Implications: The definition crafted from the research study provides a compelling conceptualisation of a phenomenon that is often described from only a philosophical or political perspective. This empirical research study contributes to the leadership debate by providing a multidimensional and comprehensive definition of African business leadership, incorporating both the positive and negative elements.

Leadership talent mindset as a catalyst for talent management and talent retention: The case of a Botswana local government institution

“…According to Kravariti et al (2022) and Mangisa et al (2020), leadership is an essential catalyst for preventing voluntary turnover intentions in poor talent management practice in government institutions. Therefore, leadership prominence and competence are paramount for Botswana local government institutions to curb adverse outcomes on talented employees and remain sustainable (Cheteni & Shindika, 2017;Lerutla & Steyn, 2021;Marobela, 2020).…”

“…Therefore, it is not surprising that the Global Competitiveness Report ranks sub-Saharan African countries poorly in human capital development (Schwab & Zahidi, 2020). Moreover, the need exists for more leadership prominence and competence in African enterprises that can drive the sustainable goals and vision for the continent through talent (Cheteni & Shindika, 2017;Lerutla & Steyn, 2021). Shingenge and Saurombe (2022) mentioned that limited empirical information exists on leadership viewpoints and perceptions regarding local government institutions in sub-Saharan Africa.…”

The influence of follower orientation on follower behaviour in the leadership process

“…We applied the study by Carsten et al (2017) in a South African environment to offer evidence of followership in this unique cultural context that differs from that in China in terms of China having higher power distance than the general South African population (See GLOBE study in House et al, 2004;Hofstede, 2011). In conducting this research on the African continent, we wish to contribute to the growing body of knowledge by African scholars, in accordance with the observations of Nkomo (2011), Lerutla and Steyn (2021), Vilakati and Schurink (2021) and Sanda (2017) that leadership studies were predominantly conducted in Europe and the Americas, which raise arguments as to whether their assumptions hold true for those leaders (and followers) operating in the African firm environment.…”

Mapping the trajectory of organizational leadership development: A bibliometric analysis

“…In that research, authors conducted a comprehensive, objective and integrative review of leadership development field. Besides, some empirical research has been also conducted and published in reputed journals about leadership but more research on the conceptualization of leadership development trends needed to incorporate both positive and negative elements in the field of business and management (Lerutla-Steyn, 2021;Farkas et al, 2021). Though, few systematic and comprehensive review articles have appeared in the last couple of years.…”