After Postpositivism? The Promises of Critical Realism

Abstract

This article argues that the current self-understanding of IR theory is misconceived and that it is time to move beyond the stagnant positivism0 postpositivism debate. We argue that the attempt to occupy a middle ground compromise position between positivism and postpositivism is untenable because these two positions share much in common. In this sense a middle ground position between two problematic positions does not produce a less problematic position. What is needed is a metatheoretical analysis of the two extreme positions. We attempt to show how both positivism and postpositivism are embedded in a discourse of philosophical anti-realism. This anti-realism occurs as a result of what we call the post-Kantian-Humean "problem-field" of international relations from which most contemporary positivist, constructivist, and poststructuralist IR approaches stem. We then try to overcome this "problemfield" by means of radically reclaiming reality through a critical realist philosophy. Once outlined we try to show how this critical realist philosophy can help transcend some of the antinomies currently faced by IR scholars.

An Assessment of the Impact of the Mentoring Programme on Student Performance

“…Bhaskar's critical realism asserts that the world is composed of three strata or layers, that is discourses, structures, powers and tendencies at the level of the Real; events at the level of the Actual; and experiences and impressions at the level of the Empirical (Bhaskar, 1979;Patomaki & Wight, 2000;Sayer, 2007). Therefore, for the purposes of this study, the researchers were interested in unearthing the tendencies at the level of the Real which contributed to the outcome of an improved academic performance at the level of the Empirical.…”

Przyczynowość w nauce o stosunkach międzynarodowych

“…Keohane do refleksywistów w NSM zaliczył Haywarda Alkera, Richarda Ashley, Friedricha Kratochwila i Johna Ruggie (Keohane, 1988, s. 381-382). Podział ten jest szeroko przywoływany w NSM (Patomäki, Wight, 2000;Waever, 2009).…”

Global cities and the transformation of the International System

“…Joseph (2007) Wight (2007) Chernoff (2007) Brown (2007. 106 Wight and Patomaki (2000) 107 Wendt (1999: 47-138) 108 Kurki (2007) Weber, that we should renounce the goal of objectivity, and embrace the inevitably partial and culturally conditioned nature of our theories as subjective portrayals o f the world. In this reading, the Western obsession with progress towards achieving certain knowledge is seen as a cultural value commitment, specific to a particular time and place.112…”