Age estimation of individuals aged 5–23 years based on dental development of the Indonesian population

Abstract

Dental development can be used to estimate age for forensic purposes. However, most of the currently available methods are less reliable for the Indonesian population due to population variability. This study presents a new method and evaluates other methods that utilize dental development to estimate the age of Indonesian people. Panoramic radiographs of 304 young Indonesian people aged 5-23 years old were analysed for deciduous tooth root resorption, permanent tooth calcification, and eruption. The extent of tooth root resorption was determined based on AlQahtani's modified Moorrees et al. method. Tooth calcification was classified based on a modified Demirjian et al. method. Tooth eruption was evaluated based on AlQahtani's modified Bengston system. The sequence of tooth root resorption, and permanent tooth calcification and eruption were grouped into 19 age categories (from 5-23 years old) in an atlas. The differences between males and females, between maxillary and mandibular teeth, and between right and left teeth were also analysed. There were minimal significant differences of tooth development between males and females, and between the right and left teeth (P > 0.05), while the maxillary and mandibular dental development was significantly different (P < 0.05). The newly developed atlas showed the development of the right side of maxillary and mandibular tooth of combined sex of Indonesian population. Another 34 panoramic radiographs of known-age and sex individuals from Indonesia were assessed using the newly developed Atlas of Dental Development in the Indonesian Population, Ubelaker's Dental Development Chart, The London Atlas of Human Tooth Development and Eruption by AlQahtani, and the Age Estimation Guide-Modern Australia population by Blenkin-Taylor. Accuracy was assessed by comparing estimated age to actual chronological age using the Bland-Altmand test. Results show that the smallest range of error was found in the Atlas of Dental Development in the Indonesian Population (−0.969 to 1.210 years), followed by The London Atlas of Human Tooth Development and Eruption by AlQahtani (−2.013 to 1.990 years), the Age Estimation Guide-Modern Australia population by Blenkin-Taylor (−2.495 to 2.598 years), the Dental Development Chart by Ubelaker (−2.960 to 3.289 years). These findings show that the Atlas of Dental Development constructed in this study performs better than the other three methods and presents greater accuracy of age estimation in the Indonesian population. KEY POINTS• Dental development such as deciduous tooth root resorption, permanent tooth calcification, and tooth eruption can be used to estimate age for forensic purposes. • The development of the teeth are influenced by genetic, ethnicity, and sex, therefore an age estimation method must be constructed based on the same population. • There were minimal significant differences in tooth development between male and female, and between right and left teeth, but there was significant difference between maxillary and mandibular teeth. • The A...

Employing the London Atlas in the Age Estimation of a Select South African Population

“…Pavlovic et al [ 27 ] further elaborated that the side used for age estimation will not influence the results. Therefore, this study only evaluated the right side of the mandible and maxilla, which was in keeping with the studies conducted by AlQahtani et al [ 7 ], Esan and Schepartz [ 13 ] and Putri et al [ 22 ].…”

“…Previous literary reports noted no statistically significant difference between the chronological age and estimated dental age on the right and left side of the jaw [ 22 , 27 , 31 ]. Pavlovic et al [ 27 ] further elaborated that the side used for age estimation will not influence the results.…”

“…However, dental maturity occurred at 20.5 and 21.5 years in the SA Black and Indian populations in the KZN Atlases, respectively. In addition, the Indonesian Atlas of Tooth Development recorded dental maturity between 22 and 24 years in the Indonesian population [ 22 ]. Literary findings reported that children of African ancestry have advanced tooth development and emergence compared to those of European ancestry, hence attributing to the slightly earlier dental maturity in the SA Black population [ 13 , 34 , 35 , 36 ].…”

“…If a category displayed an equal frequency for two or more developmental stages, then the more advanced stage was assigned [ 13 ]. The mode value was used instead of the median value for each stage, as not every variable has a median stage if there is an even number of stages [ 22 ]. Moreover, in accordance with AlQahtani et al [ 7 ] and Esan and Schepartz [ 13 ], the age cohorts in the KZN Atlases were represented in mid-year intervals.…”

Tooth and Bone Parameters in the Assessment of the Chronological Age of Children and Adolescents Using Neural Modelling Methods

“…Most recent work on metric age assessment is based on traditional, atlas-based methods [61,62]. There are also works on adult age assessment [63][64][65]. It seems that the challenge of the 21st century is to develop modern tools that would allow measurements and classifications to be made automatically.…”