Early Proterozoic oceanic crust exposed in a shear zone in the northern Colorado Front Range provides insight into the tectonic evolution of the Colorado province. Tectonically intermingled mylonitic amphibolite (locally pillowed), metagabbro, clinopyroxenite, metachert, and mélange are preserved within the Buckhorn Creek shear zone west of Fort Collins. Whole rock geochemical data support formation of the igneous protoliths in an oceanic environment. Major and trace element data overlap samples from modern oceanic ridges, and are distinct from modern arc trends. Metagabbros and clinopyroxenites preserve a subhorizontal lineation defined by igneous pyroxenes; core and mantle microstructures indicate initial deformation at temperatures >900°C. Secondary amphiboles define both subhorizontal and subvertical lineations. Kinematic analysis indicates that the rocks experienced E‐W strike‐slip deformation prior to and during amphibolite‐facies metamorphism, followed by N‐S shortening. 40Ar/39Ar data from secondary hornblende yield age steps as old as 1.9 Ga. Based on the chemical data and kinematic evidence for strike‐slip deformation, we propose that the Buckhorn Creek rocks originated at an oceanic ridge‐transform intersection. The high‐T pyroxene fabrics formed during ocean floor deformation prior to 1.7 Ga regional deformation of the Colorado province. The Buckhorn Creek fragment likely represents original oceanic basement for 1.8–1.7 Ga arc magmatism and sedimentation that ultimately formed the Colorado province continental crust. Reactivation of original oceanic fracture zones may be responsible for the network of regularly spaced northeast trending shear zones in Colorado. Once formed, subvertical transform faults are likely to survive the transition from oceanic to continental crust and persist as long‐lived crustal discontinuities.